Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Gomez v. Schindler Elevator Corp. — Court dismissed elevator-injury claims against maintenance contractor

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Michael Gomez v. Schindler Elevator Corporation, Galium Millennium, LLC, Greystar GP, LLC, and GREP Texas, LLC
Court
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas
Judge
Sim Lake
Date Decided
August 17, 2026
Docket No.
4:25-cv-02998
Topics
Premises Liability; Negligence; Elevators; Summary Judgment

Background

Michael Gomez alleged that he was injured while visiting his mother at Millennium High Street Apartments. As he retrieved groceries from the floor near an elevator, Gomez placed his leg between the elevator doors to keep them open. The doors continued closing, and a door struck his elbow, causing him to trip and fall over the groceries. He claimed injuries to his elbow and lower back.

Gomez sued the apartment-related entities and Schindler Elevator Corporation, which maintained the property’s five elevators under a contract with Galium Millennium. He asserted premises-liability and negligence claims. Schindler moved for traditional and no-evidence summary judgment, and Gomez did not respond. Although local rules treated the motion as unopposed, the court independently considered whether Schindler had established its entitlement to judgment.

The Court’s Holding

The court granted Schindler’s motion and dismissed Gomez’s claims against it with prejudice. It held that Texas law did not permit Gomez to pursue an ordinary-negligence theory based on the same allegedly dangerous premises condition underlying his premises-liability claim. The court added that any negligence claim would also fail because Gomez had not designated expert testimony concerning the elevator’s maintenance and operation.

On premises liability, the court found a genuine factual dispute over whether Schindler’s contractual maintenance responsibilities gave it sufficient control over the elevator to owe Gomez a duty. Summary judgment nevertheless was warranted because Gomez produced no evidence that Schindler had actual or constructive knowledge of the allegedly defective doors. There was no evidence showing how long the condition had existed, that Galium had notified Schindler of a door or sensor problem, or that Schindler had failed to inspect the elevator with reasonable frequency. The available inspection records indicated that the elevator operated properly during inspections conducted in 2019, 2021, and twice in 2024.

Key Takeaways

  • A plaintiff cannot recast a Texas premises-defect claim as ordinary negligence when the alleged injury arose from a dangerous condition rather than a contemporaneous activity.
  • A maintenance contractor may exercise sufficient control to owe a premises-liability duty even when its contract states that possession and control remain with the property owner.
  • Evidence of actual or constructive knowledge remains essential; without evidence that the defect was known or existed long enough to be discovered through reasonable inspection, a premises-liability claim fails.

Why It Matters

The decision illustrates that contractual maintenance duties can create a fact question about a contractor’s control of equipment, but control alone does not establish premises liability. Plaintiffs must also offer evidence connecting the contractor to knowledge of the specific dangerous condition.

It also underscores that an unanswered summary-judgment motion is not granted automatically. The movant must still demonstrate that the record and governing law entitle it to judgment.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top