Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Zenith Surgery Center — court dismisses duplicative ERISA fiduciary-duty claim but lets benefits and some state-law theories proceed

Reported / Citable

Case
Zenith Surgery Center, PLLC v. TE Connectivity
Court
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas
Judge
Lee H. Rosenthal, Senior United States District Judge
Date Decided
August 17, 2026
Docket No.
H-25-3867
Topics
ERISA; healthcare reimbursement; anti-assignment clauses; ERISA preemption

Background

Zenith Surgery Center treated TE Connectivity employee Steven Kelly from June through December 2020 after verifying his coverage under TE Connectivity’s health-benefits plan. Kelly assigned his plan-benefit rights to Zenith, which alleges it provided medically necessary services worth $748,221.19 and timely submitted its claims under COVID-era deadline extensions.

Zenith alleged that TE Connectivity improperly denied the claims, including by treating them as untimely. It sued for ERISA benefits, ERISA breach of fiduciary duty, and Texas-law breach of contract, promissory estoppel, and quantum meruit. TE Connectivity moved to dismiss, relying on the plan’s anti-assignment provision, alleged deficient pleading and failure to exhaust, duplicative ERISA remedies, and ERISA preemption.

The Court’s Holding

Judge Rosenthal granted the motion only as to Zenith’s ERISA fiduciary-duty claim under § 502(a)(3). That claim sought redress for the same alleged underpayment of benefits addressed by Zenith’s § 502(a)(1)(B) benefits claim, and Fifth Circuit precedent does not permit both claims where the benefits remedy is adequate.

The court held that Zenith plausibly alleged standing notwithstanding the anti-assignment clause because Zenith alleged it verified coverage, was not told of the clause, and relied on coverage representations before treating Kelly. Whether estoppel prevents enforcement of the clause is fact-bound and requires discovery. The benefits claim was sufficiently pleaded, and the complaint’s silence on administrative appeals did not establish the affirmative defense of failure to exhaust.

The court also declined to dismiss the state-law claims wholesale. Claims based on improper plan administration are preempted, but claims based on independent, misleading representations made to Zenith during coverage verification may not be. The preemption issue requires a more developed record.

Key Takeaways

  • An anti-assignment clause does not compel dismissal where a provider plausibly alleges estoppel based on undisclosed coverage-related representations.
  • In the Fifth Circuit, an ERISA fiduciary-duty claim cannot proceed alongside a benefits claim when both seek relief for the same unpaid benefits.
  • Provider claims based on independent verification-of-coverage representations may avoid ERISA preemption.

Why It Matters

The decision underscores that healthcare providers can survive dismissal of assigned ERISA-benefits claims despite anti-assignment language when the provider plausibly alleges reliance on the plan’s own coverage representations. The enforceability question may depend on discovery into communications and the parties’ course of dealing.

It also preserves a path for providers to pursue state-law theories based on independent promises or misleading omissions, while separating those claims from theories that merely challenge administration of an ERISA plan.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top