Reported / Citable
Background
Helal Safi, an Afghan citizen who alleged persecution by the Taliban because of his family’s connections to Afghanistan’s former government, entered the United States in November 2024 and surrendered to immigration authorities. An immigration judge found him removable on July 31, 2025, but granted withholding of removal to Afghanistan under the Immigration and Nationality Act. Neither side appealed, making the removal order final.
Safi remained detained throughout the proceedings and for more than 20 months overall. Because he could not be returned to Afghanistan, immigration officials sought State Department assistance in finding a third country, but identified no destination or expected removal date. Safi petitioned for habeas relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2241, arguing under Zadvydas v. Davis that his continued, potentially indefinite detention violated federal law and due process.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Richard B. Farrer recommended granting Safi’s amended habeas petition and ordering his release, subject to lawful execution of the final removal order and, if appropriate, minimal conditions of supervision. The report concluded that the district court had jurisdiction over Safi’s challenge to indefinite post-removal-order detention.
The magistrate judge found that Safi’s statutory 90-day removal period expired on October 29, 2025, and that his detention had also exceeded the six-month period considered presumptively reasonable under Zadvydas. Safi provided good reason to believe that removal was not significantly likely in the reasonably foreseeable future, while the government failed to rebut that showing. Its statements that officials were working toward third-country removal, without identifying a destination, timeline, or concrete progress, did not establish a foreseeable removal.
Key Takeaways
- This decision is a magistrate judge’s report and recommendation, not a final district-court judgment; the parties may object before the district judge acts on it.
- Once detention exceeds the presumptively reasonable six-month period, evidence that no country or removal timeline has been identified can satisfy a detainee’s initial burden under Zadvydas.
- General assurances that agencies are pursuing third-country removal do not rebut that showing when they provide no concrete evidence about the timing or likelihood of removal.
Why It Matters
The recommendation underscores that the government’s authority to enforce a final removal order does not permit detention for an indefinite and undetermined period. When removal to the detainee’s home country is barred, officials must offer meaningful evidence that removal to another country is significantly likely within the reasonably foreseeable future.
The report also illustrates the distinction between release from detention and cancellation of a removal order: Safi would remain subject to his final order, which the government could execute later through lawful procedures.