Reported / Citable
Background
Cynthia Fitzgerald filed the lawsuit in Texas state court. Defendant Corinthian Capital Group, LLC removed it before any named defendant had been served, invoking diversity jurisdiction. After the district court questioned whether complete diversity existed, Corinthian filed an amended notice and additional citizenship information.
Fitzgerald timely moved to remand, arguing that removal violated the rule of unanimity. She contended that Excelin Holdings, LLC could not validly consent because Texas records showed that the company was inactive and had forfeited its existence. Defendants later filed a joint notice of removal after Excelin Holdings’ registration was reinstated.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge David L. Horan recommended denying Fitzgerald’s motion to remand. Because no defendant had been served when Corinthian filed the amended notice of removal, the rule of unanimity did not require the other defendants to join in or consent to removal. Any possible defect in Excelin Holdings’ purported consent therefore did not make the removal procedurally improper.
The magistrate judge declined to rely on the later joint notice of removal. It was filed outside Corinthian’s 30-day removal period and without leave, so it could not cure a procedural defect. That did not affect the recommended result, however, because Corinthian had not needed its unserved codefendants’ consent in the first place. The document was a findings, conclusions, and recommendation subject to objections and review by the district judge, not a final remand ruling.
Key Takeaways
- The removal statute requires consent only from defendants who have been properly joined and served.
- An unserved codefendant’s alleged inability to consent does not violate the rule of unanimity when its consent was unnecessary.
- A notice filed after the 30-day removal period generally cannot cure a substantive procedural defect in removal, although later clarification of imperfect jurisdictional allegations may be permitted.
Why It Matters
The recommendation illustrates the procedural distinction between complete diversity and the forum-defendant and unanimity rules. Complete diversity remains necessary in a snap-removal case, but unserved defendants need not consent to removal.
It also underscores that defendants should correct procedural removal defects within the statutory 30-day period. Here, the late joint notice could not supply a cure, but remand was still unwarranted because no consent defect existed.