Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

NexPoint v. Highland — Fifth Circuit affirmed an $825,940.55 bad-faith sanction

Reported / Citable

Case
In the Matter of Highland Capital Management, L.P.; NexPoint Real Estate Partners, L.L.C. v. Highland Capital Management, L.P.
Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Judge
Stewart (Bill Clinton, 1994); Graves (Barack Obama, 2011); Wilson (Donald J. Trump, 2020)
Date Decided
August 14, 2026
Docket No.
25-11185
Topics
Bankruptcy; Sanctions; Bad Faith; Attorney Fees
Source
Read the full opinion

Background

Highland Capital Management and HCRE Partners, now known as NexPoint Real Estate Partners, participated in a real-estate investment project through SE Multifamily Holdings, LLC. After Highland entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy, HCRE filed a proof of claim asserting that SE Multifamily’s governing documents mistakenly understated HCRE’s membership interest and seeking reformation of the amended LLC agreement.

The bankruptcy court rejected the claim after a bench trial. It later found that HCRE had filed and litigated the claim in bad faith, including by pursuing a claim its officers knew lacked a factual basis, misrepresenting conflicted counsel’s prior role, and attempting to withdraw the claim shortly before officer depositions while preserving the underlying dispute for another forum. Exercising its inherent authority, the bankruptcy court awarded Highland $825,940.55 in attorney fees. The district court affirmed.

The Court’s Holding

The Fifth Circuit affirmed. It held that a bankruptcy court’s inherent-power sanction requires a finding of bad faith or willful abuse of the judicial process supported by clear and convincing evidence. On appeal, the court independently reviews the legal sufficiency of that evidence rather than applying clear-error review to the bankruptcy court’s determination that the evidentiary threshold was met.

Clear and convincing evidence supported the bad-faith finding. Dondero filed the proof of claim without meaningful investigation, while trial testimony from him and McGraner showed that the LLC agreement reflected the parties’ intended ownership allocation. The record also supported findings that HCRE knowingly advanced a frivolous position in opposing its counsel’s disqualification and strategically sought withdrawal to avoid discovery without foreclosing a later challenge elsewhere.

The fee award was compensatory rather than impermissibly punitive because the awarded fees were causally linked to HCRE’s misconduct. That link included fees incurred after the attempted withdrawal: HCRE required court permission to withdraw once Highland objected, failed to propose terms that would conclusively prevent renewed litigation, and thereby made continued merits litigation necessary. The bankruptcy court did not award fees incurred litigating the sanctions motion itself.

Key Takeaways

  • Inherent-power bankruptcy sanctions require clear and convincing evidence of bad faith or willful abuse of the judicial process.
  • The Fifth Circuit reviews the legal sufficiency of evidence supporting an inherent-power bad-faith finding without deference, then reviews the sanction’s substance for abuse of discretion.
  • A fee-shifting sanction may include post-withdrawal-motion expenses when the sanctioned party’s conduct caused continued litigation and the fees remain causally tied to that misconduct.

Why It Matters

The decision underscores that filing a proof of claim without investigation and then using discovery or withdrawal tactics to preserve a baseless dispute can expose a creditor to substantial fee-shifting sanctions. A party seeking to withdraw a contested claim cannot assume that offering dismissal “with prejudice” will end the matter if the proposed disposition leaves room to revive the underlying controversy elsewhere.

The opinion also clarifies the Fifth Circuit’s appellate framework for inherent-power sanctions: close, nondeferential scrutiny applies to whether clear and convincing evidence supports bad faith, while the nature and amount of a properly grounded sanction are reviewed for abuse of discretion.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top