Reported / Citable
Background
Jose Mauricio Lopez-Barrera, an alien from El Salvador, sought asylum and protection under the regulations implementing the Convention Against Torture. After multiple proceedings and two Board of Immigration Appeals remands, an immigration judge denied his request for CAT deferral, finding that his testimony was not credible.
On the final remand, the immigration judge also denied Lopez-Barrera’s request to submit new evidence for lack of good cause. The Board affirmed, and Lopez-Barrera petitioned the Fifth Circuit for review, challenging the denial of his motions to remand, amend his asylum application again, and submit late evidence, as well as the denial of CAT relief.
The Court’s Holding
The Fifth Circuit denied the petition. It held that the Board did not abuse its discretion by declining to remand for evidence concerning El Salvador’s crackdown on gangs because the evidence was unlikely to change the outcome. It also upheld the refusal to permit another amended asylum application and the immigration judge’s rejection of late-filed evidence, noting that Lopez-Barrera had ample opportunity to submit documents.
The court further held that 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2) did not eliminate jurisdiction to review the evidentiary-continuance determination in this CAT proceeding. On the merits, substantial evidence supported the adverse-credibility finding because Lopez-Barrera gave materially inconsistent accounts of the events underlying his asserted fear of return. Substantial evidence also supported the finding that he failed to present particularized proof that he was more likely than not to be tortured with a public official’s consent or acquiescence; generalized evidence about conditions in El Salvador was insufficient.
Key Takeaways
- Section 1252(a)(2) did not bar review of the immigration judge’s refusal to accept late evidence in this proceeding.
- Material inconsistencies about the incidents allegedly creating a risk of torture supported the agency’s adverse-credibility finding.
- General country-condition evidence did not establish that Lopez-Barrera personally was more likely than not to face government-sanctioned torture in El Salvador.
Why It Matters
The decision clarifies the Fifth Circuit’s jurisdiction to review an immigration judge’s discretionary handling of late evidence when the relevant discretion arises from regulation rather than a statutory provision covered by § 1252(a)(2). It also reinforces that CAT applicants must provide credible, individualized evidence connecting country conditions to a probable risk of torture.