Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Island Peak Group v. Ownwell — Court lets false-advertising and Texas unfair-competition claims proceed but dismisses abandoned federal unfair-competition claim

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Island Peak Group, LLC d/b/a Texas Tax Protest v. Ownwell, Inc.
Court
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas
Judge
Sidney A. Fitzwater
Date Decided
June 10, 2025
Docket No.
3:24-cv-03135-D
Topics
False Advertising; Lanham Act; Unfair Competition; Pleading Standards

Background

Island Peak Group, LLC, doing business as Texas Tax Protest, and Ownwell, Inc. compete in the property-tax consulting market. These firms seek reductions in assessed property values and typically receive a percentage of their clients’ resulting tax savings.

Texas Tax Protest alleged that Ownwell used an inflated 2.5% property-tax rate when estimating potential savings for consumers, including property owners in Travis County. According to the complaint, the inflated rate made Ownwell’s projected savings appear larger than those offered by competitors, causing consumers—including former Texas Tax Protest clients—to hire Ownwell instead.

Texas Tax Protest asserted Lanham Act claims for false advertising and unfair competition, along with a Texas common-law unfair-competition claim. Ownwell moved to dismiss all claims under Rule 12(b)(6).

The Court’s Holding

The court held that Texas Tax Protest plausibly pleaded Lanham Act false advertising. Accepting the complaint’s allegations as true, the court found that describing 2.5% as an “average” or “estimate” could still mislead consumers because the alleged average Travis County rate was approximately 1.85%, while Ownwell’s own website allegedly identified an average rate of 1.31%. The qualifying language was not sufficiently clarifying to defeat the claim as a matter of law.

The court also found the injury allegations—though “borderline adequate”—sufficient because Texas Tax Protest alleged that Ownwell’s advertising diverted customers and legacy clients from it. The court therefore denied dismissal of the false-advertising claim and the parallel Texas common-law unfair-competition claim.

The court dismissed with prejudice the separate Lanham Act unfair-competition claim because Texas Tax Protest appeared to have abandoned it. The motion to dismiss was therefore granted in part and denied in part.

Key Takeaways

  • Calling a numerical representation an “average” or “estimate” does not necessarily prevent it from being actionable when the alleged figure may create a materially false impression.
  • Allegations that deceptive advertising diverted customers and legacy clients can plausibly plead the direct economic injury required for a Lanham Act false-advertising claim.
  • A claim left undefended in response to a dismissal motion may be treated as abandoned and dismissed with prejudice.

Why It Matters

The ruling allows Texas Tax Protest to pursue claims that Ownwell’s advertised tax-rate assumptions overstated prospective customers’ savings. It also underscores that disclaimers and qualifying terms will not automatically resolve whether an advertisement is misleading at the pleading stage.

For competitors challenging advertising practices, the decision illustrates that concrete allegations of customer diversion may suffice to establish injury, even when the court views those allegations as close to the pleading threshold.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top