Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Pham v. NewRez — Magistrate judge recommends denying remand of foreclosure dispute

Reported / Citable

Case
Ann Tram Pham v. NewRez LLC d/b/a Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing
Court
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, Austin Division
Judge
Susan Hightower, United States Magistrate Judge
Date Decided
May 28, 2026
Docket No.
1:26-cv-00562-ADA-SH
Topics
Removal, Diversity Jurisdiction, Federal Question Jurisdiction, Foreclosure

Background

Ann Tram Pham sued NewRez LLC in Texas state court to prevent foreclosure on her Austin condominium. She alleged that NewRez, which serviced her mortgage, continued foreclosure activity while her loss-mitigation application was pending, violating the federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act and the Texas Debt Collection Act. She sought injunctive relief preventing foreclosure until the disputes were resolved.

NewRez removed the action to federal court based on federal-question and diversity jurisdiction. Pham moved to remand, arguing that the amount in controversy did not exceed $75,000 and that the court should abstain because the case predominantly involved state-law issues. She did not dispute that the parties were citizens of different states.

The Court’s Holding

Magistrate Judge Susan Hightower recommended denying Pham’s motion to remand. Because Pham sought to enjoin foreclosure and preserve her ownership interest, the property itself was the object of the litigation and its value determined the amount in controversy. NewRez submitted a county appraisal valuing the property at $801,289 in 2025, which established an amount exceeding the $75,000 jurisdictional threshold.

The magistrate judge also concluded that federal-question jurisdiction independently existed because Pham alleged a violation of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act. The report rejected her request for abstention, stating that the court could not abstain from exercising jurisdiction over the claims. The ruling was a report and recommendation to the district judge, not a final disposition of the remand motion.

Key Takeaways

  • When a plaintiff seeks to stop foreclosure and preserve ownership, the property’s value may measure the amount in controversy.
  • A 2025 appraisal valuing the condominium at $801,289 satisfied the amount required for diversity jurisdiction.
  • Pham’s RESPA claim separately supplied federal-question jurisdiction, and the magistrate judge recommended denying remand.

Why It Matters

The recommendation illustrates that a borrower cannot defeat diversity jurisdiction merely by characterizing requested injunctive relief as having a value below the property or loan amount. When the requested injunction would preserve ownership by stopping foreclosure, courts may treat the property as the object of the litigation.

It also shows that a pleaded federal statutory claim can independently support removal even when the complaint includes related state-law claims. Because this was a magistrate judge’s report and recommendation, the district judge retained responsibility for the final ruling after the objection period.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top