Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Andrew Anthony III brought a personal-injury action against Vernon Gorney and The RV Factory, LLC in Texas state court. The defendants removed the case to the Eastern District of Texas based on diversity jurisdiction.
Anthony moved to admit billing affidavits and medical bills under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 18.001. That statute provides a method for establishing the reasonableness and necessity of charges through affidavits unless the opposing party serves a controverting affidavit. The defendants filed neither a response to the motion nor controverting affidavits.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted Anthony’s motion. It held that § 18.001 applies in federal diversity cases to the extent the statute permits affidavits to prove the reasonableness and necessity of medical expenses.
The court reasoned that state law governs recoverable damages and the manner in which those damages must be proved in diversity cases. Agreeing with other Eastern District of Texas decisions, it treated § 18.001’s affidavit mechanism as substantive, while noting precedent characterizing the statute’s filing deadlines as procedural. Because the defendants did not respond, dispute the motion, or file controverting affidavits, the court permitted Anthony to use his affidavits and bills at trial.
Key Takeaways
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 18.001 applies in federal diversity actions insofar as it permits affidavits to establish the reasonableness and necessity of medical expenses.
- The court distinguished the statute’s substantive proof mechanism from its procedural filing deadlines.
- The defendants did not object, respond to the motion, or submit controverting affidavits.
Why It Matters
The decision confirms that, in this court, a personal-injury plaintiff may use § 18.001 billing affidavits to prove the reasonableness and necessity of medical expenses without presenting an expert witness for that purpose. It also underscores the consequences of failing to respond to such a motion or serve controverting affidavits.