Reported / Citable
Background
Davantae London robbed several Houston-area Walmart stores at gunpoint. Under his plea agreement, the government agreed to dismiss nine counts from the superseding indictment, and London waived his right to appeal his conviction and sentence.
When London nevertheless appealed, the Fifth Circuit initially granted the government’s motion to dismiss. After the Supreme Court held in Hunter v. United States that an appeal waiver is unenforceable when enforcement would result in a miscarriage of justice, the Supreme Court granted London’s petition for certiorari, vacated the Fifth Circuit’s judgment, and remanded the case for reconsideration.
The Court’s Holding
The Fifth Circuit again enforced London’s appeal waiver and dismissed the appeal. London argued that enforcing the waiver would cause a miscarriage of justice because the district court allegedly violated U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3 by ordering his federal sentence to run consecutively to his state sentence.
The court held that London’s claim was a routine challenge to the district court’s application of the Sentencing Guidelines, not the kind of egregious error that threatens the justice system’s basic integrity. Even assuming a Guidelines error occurred, such a standard sentencing-law error could not invalidate the appeal waiver under Hunter.
Key Takeaways
- An appeal waiver remains enforceable unless enforcing it would produce the kind of egregious error that brings the judicial system into disrepute.
- Potential miscarriage-of-justice errors include sentences exceeding statutory limits, sentences infected by blatant constitutional error, and sentences imposed without minimally civilized procedures.
- An ordinary claim that a district court misapplied the Sentencing Guidelines does not overcome an otherwise enforceable appeal waiver.
Why It Matters
The decision applies the Supreme Court’s new miscarriage-of-justice exception narrowly. In the Fifth Circuit, defendants who waived their appellate rights generally cannot revive an appeal merely by alleging a conventional Guidelines error.
For plea negotiations and sentencing appeals, the ruling confirms that appeal waivers continue to foreclose most sentencing challenges, while reserving relief for errors that threaten the justice system’s fundamental integrity.