Reported / Citable
Background
Osman Rene Lara-Melgar appeared with counsel before U.S. Magistrate Judge Matthew H. Watters for a felony guilty-plea proceeding. The case had been referred to the magistrate judge under a general order for the taking of the plea.
After being advised of his right to have the plea taken by a district judge, Lara-Melgar consented to proceed before the magistrate judge. He pleaded guilty, without a plea agreement, to Count One of the indictment, charging illegal reentry into the United States.
The Court’s Holding
Judge Watters found that Lara-Melgar understood the charge, the potential penalties, and his constitutional and statutory rights; that he knowingly and voluntarily waived those rights; and that he was competent to plead guilty. The magistrate judge also found a sufficient factual basis for the plea.
The magistrate judge found Lara-Melgar guilty of the charge to which he pleaded and recommended that the district court accept the guilty plea and enter a judgment of guilt. The matter was referred to the presiding district judge for sentencing, and the parties were advised that objections to the recommendation were due within 14 days.
Key Takeaways
- The defendant pleaded guilty to illegal reentry without a plea agreement.
- The magistrate judge concluded that the Rule 11 plea requirements were satisfied.
- The acceptance of the plea and entry of judgment remained subject to the district judge’s consideration of the recommendation.
Why It Matters
The filing is a report and recommendation, not a final district-court judgment accepting the plea. It establishes the magistrate judge’s findings that the plea was knowing, voluntary, competent, and supported by an adequate factual basis, while preserving the parties’ opportunity to object before district-court review.