Reported / Citable
Background
Jose Reinaldo Lara Coreas filed a habeas petition seeking release from immigration custody during his immigration proceedings. He also moved to prevent the government from transferring him to another district or removing him from the United States while the district court considered the habeas petition.
Lara Coreas argued that an anti-transfer or anti-removal order was necessary to let him pursue his claims adequately and to preserve the court’s ability to adjudicate them.
The Court’s Holding
Judge Leon Schydlower denied the motion. The court explained that habeas jurisdiction attaches when a petition is initially filed, and a government-initiated transfer to a facility in another judicial district does not automatically eliminate that jurisdiction.
The court also held that it lacked jurisdiction over a request to prevent removal. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g), federal courts lack jurisdiction over claims directly connected to decisions or actions to execute removal orders, and a request to stay removal challenges a removal order.
Key Takeaways
- A transfer after a properly filed habeas petition does not automatically divest the district court of habeas jurisdiction.
- The court found no basis to bar a transfer merely to preserve a detained petitioner’s access to the court.
- A district court lacks jurisdiction to stay removal when the request directly challenges execution of a removal order.
Why It Matters
The order distinguishes challenges to immigration detention from efforts to halt removal. A pending habeas case may remain before the original court after a transfer, but that does not give the court jurisdiction to enjoin execution of a removal order.