Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Luis Alberto Bachez Rivera, a citizen of El Salvador, entered the United States in 2024 and was immediately placed in immigration detention. An immigration judge denied his applications for relief and ordered him removed, but his timely appeal remained pending, so the removal order was not final.
Bachez Rivera petitioned for habeas relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2241, arguing that his prolonged detention without a bond hearing violated the Fifth Amendment. He also cited his good conduct, asserted that he was not a flight risk, and alleged that detention was harming his mental and physical health. The government moved for summary judgment, contending that he was an applicant for admission subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b).
The Court’s Holding
The court granted the government summary judgment and denied the habeas petition. It held that Bachez Rivera was an applicant for admission because he was present in the country without having been admitted and therefore was subject to mandatory detention under § 1225(b) while his removal proceedings remained pending. The court concluded that the statute and the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Buenrostro-Mendez v. Bondi foreclosed his statutory challenge.
The court also rejected both substantive and procedural due-process challenges. It held that detention during ongoing removal proceedings is a constitutionally permissible part of the removal process and that Zadvydas v. Davis, which concerns post-removal-order detention, did not govern. Because applicants for admission receive the process Congress prescribed and § 1225(b) does not require bond hearings, the court found no procedural violation. It further held that claims concerning deteriorating health and other conditions of confinement were not cognizable in habeas because they did not challenge the cause of detention.
The court declined to rely on the vacated panel opinion in Sosnava Rodriguez v. Ortega. Because the Fifth Circuit had granted rehearing en banc, vacated that opinion, and stayed the underlying judgments, the panel decision had no precedential value.
Key Takeaways
- A noncitizen present in the United States without having been admitted is an applicant for admission subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b).
- The court held that an applicant for admission whose removal proceedings remain pending has no statutory or constitutional right to a bond hearing.
- Health-related conditions-of-confinement claims cannot support habeas relief when they do not challenge the legal basis for custody.
Why It Matters
The decision applies the Fifth Circuit’s developing 2026 immigration-detention precedent to uphold detention throughout ongoing removal proceedings, even when detention is prolonged and no individualized bond hearing has occurred. It also underscores that a vacated appellate opinion cannot supply binding authority while rehearing en banc is pending.
For habeas practitioners, the ruling distinguishes challenges to the legality of immigration custody from complaints about conditions inside the detention facility. The latter generally must be pursued through a procedural vehicle other than habeas corpus.