Reported / Citable
Background
Timothy Morris, a federal prisoner and practicing Asatruar at FCI Big Spring, alleged that Assistant Warden Rosita Leen confiscated his copy of Odin’s Chosen: The Religion of Asatru during a search of his living area. Morris alleged that the personally inscribed, out-of-print book was central to his daily devotional study, ritual preparation, and religious guidance. He claimed that Leen disposed of the book, left a Bible on his bunk, and provided no confiscation form or notice that the book violated prison policy.
After screening Morris’s pro se complaint, the court allowed his Religious Freedom Restoration Act claim against Leen to proceed while dismissing his other claims. Leen then moved to dismiss, arguing that Morris had not plausibly alleged a RFRA violation, that qualified immunity protected her, and that the Prison Litigation Reform Act limited his damages. Morris did not file a response that the court could consider.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge John R. Parker concluded that Morris plausibly alleged a RFRA violation. Accepting the pleaded facts as true, the magistrate judge found it reasonable to infer that confiscating Odin’s Chosen prevented Morris from engaging in at least some aspects of his religious exercise. Leen’s generalized reliance on prison security and Morris’s alleged lack of ownership paperwork did not establish at the pleading stage that confiscation furthered a compelling governmental interest by the least restrictive means.
The magistrate judge nevertheless recommended dismissing the claim with prejudice because Leen was entitled to qualified immunity. Morris had not identified controlling authority or a robust consensus of persuasive authority establishing that every reasonable prison official would have understood that confiscating this particular religious book under the alleged circumstances violated RFRA. The recommendation did not reach Leen’s separate argument concerning the PLRA’s physical-injury requirement.
Key Takeaways
- An inmate plausibly alleges a substantial burden under RFRA by claiming that confiscation of a religious text entirely prevented identifiable aspects of his sincere religious practice.
- A generalized invocation of prison security does not, at the pleading stage, establish that confiscating a particular religious item was the least restrictive means of advancing a compelling governmental interest.
- Despite the plausible RFRA claim, qualified immunity applied because Morris did not identify precedent clearly establishing that confiscating the book in this specific factual context was unlawful.
Why It Matters
The recommendation illustrates that adequately pleading a RFRA violation does not necessarily permit a damages claim against an individual federal official to proceed. A prisoner must also overcome qualified immunity by identifying sufficiently specific precedent that placed the unlawfulness of the official’s conduct beyond debate.
The ruling was a magistrate judge’s findings, conclusions, and recommendation, not a final judgment on the motion. The case was transferred back to District Judge James Wesley Hendrix, and the parties were given fourteen days to file specific objections.