Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
HOPE Prison Ministries operates faith-based transitional housing and Christian rehabilitation programs for formerly incarcerated people, including registered sex offenders. It brought an as-applied challenge to a Fort Worth ordinance barring people registered for offenses involving minor victims from residing within 2,000 feet of places where children commonly gather. The ordinance also prohibits knowingly leasing or renting property for a residence barred by that restriction.
Although Fort Worth had neither cited the ministry nor taken enforcement action against it, HOPE sued based on the asserted threat of enforcement. It alleged violations of the Fair Housing Act, the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause, the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, and the Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted Fort Worth’s motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6). It held that HOPE failed to state an FHA claim because the ordinance regulates child sex offenders rather than people with disabilities, and the complaint did not plausibly allege that the ordinance caused a disparate impact on disabled individuals. It dismissed the Free Exercise claim because the ordinance was neutral and generally applicable and rationally advanced the legitimate governmental interest in protecting children. The Equal Protection claim likewise failed under rational-basis review because sex offenders are not a suspect class.
The court also held that the ordinance was not a “land use regulation” covered by RLUIPA. In the court’s view, it was a person-based residency restriction rather than a zoning or landmarking law, and its incidental effect on property use did not bring it within RLUIPA. After dismissing every federal claim, the court declined supplemental jurisdiction over the TRFRA claim. It did not conduct a Rule 12(b)(1) analysis and ordered the case dismissed with prejudice, reasoning that HOPE had already amended its complaint and had alleged its best case.
Key Takeaways
- A residency ordinance directed at child sex offenders does not support an FHA disability claim without facts connecting the restriction to disability discrimination or a disability-based disparate impact.
- The court treated Fort Worth’s ordinance as neutral and generally applicable, applying rational-basis review to the Free Exercise and Equal Protection claims.
- A person-based restriction on where sex offenders may reside is not necessarily a zoning or landmarking law subject to RLUIPA merely because it affects how property may be used.
Why It Matters
The decision illustrates the pleading barriers facing religious housing providers that challenge sex-offender residency restrictions under federal civil-rights and housing statutes. Allegations that an ordinance burdens a religious mission or affects residents with disabilities are insufficient without facts satisfying each statute’s specific coverage and causation requirements.
The ruling also distinguishes regulations of people and conduct from zoning or landmarking measures under RLUIPA, even when the regulation substantially affects the practical use of a religious organization’s property.