Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Joshua Wagner, a former Hess Corporation employee and participant in the company’s 401(k) plan, brought a putative class action alleging that Hess and its Investment Committee breached ERISA fiduciary duties by retaining investment options with excessive expense ratios. Wagner alleged that the plan should have replaced certain T. Rowe Price target-date mutual funds, other actively managed mutual funds, and Vanguard index funds with lower-cost alternatives.
After the defendants moved to dismiss the second amended complaint, Wagner sought leave to file a third amended complaint based on information obtained through discovery. The proposed allegations included that the same Investment Committee had switched from mutual funds to collective investment trusts in other Hess retirement plans and had used Morningstar categories when evaluating investments.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted leave to amend and treated the pending dismissal motion as directed at the third amended complaint. It held that Wagner plausibly stated a duty-of-prudence claim concerning the target-date funds. The complaint alleged that T. Rowe Price’s lower-cost collective trusts had the same management team, glidepath, asset exposure, tactical allocation, underlying investments, strategy, and risk as the mutual funds. Whether regulatory differences or practical considerations justified retaining the mutual funds required factual development and could not be resolved at the pleading stage.
The court dismissed with prejudice the prudence claims concerning the other mutual funds and index funds because Wagner did not plead facts showing that his proposed alternatives were equivalent in material respects; allegations that software placed funds in similar categories or that other funds tracked the same indexes were insufficient. It also dismissed the co-fiduciary-liability claim as conclusory. The failure-to-monitor claim survived only insofar as it rested on the surviving target-date-fund theory. Because Wagner was no longer a plan participant and faced no future injury, the court dismissed his request for injunctive relief for lack of standing, while holding that he had standing to seek recovery for alleged investment losses.
Key Takeaways
- An ERISA excessive-fee complaint may survive when it alleges specific facts showing that a cheaper investment is meaningfully comparable in management, strategy, holdings, risk, and expected returns.
- Merely identifying cheaper funds with similar classifications or the same tracked index does not plausibly establish an imprudent investment-selection process.
- A former plan participant may seek compensation for past investment losses but lacks standing for prospective injunctive relief absent a continuing or imminent injury.
Why It Matters
The decision illustrates the comparator detail needed to plead an ERISA excessive-fee claim. A difference in investment vehicles does not categorically prevent comparison between a mutual fund and a collective trust, but plaintiffs must allege concrete similarities rather than rely on labels, broad investment categories, or lower fees alone.
The ruling also confirms that derivative monitoring claims rise or fall with the underlying fiduciary-breach theory and that co-fiduciary liability requires factual allegations beyond a recitation of ERISA’s statutory elements.