Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Monica Renee Metcalf appealed the Northern District of Texas’s judgment revoking her supervised release. The district court imposed six months’ imprisonment followed by an additional term of supervised release.
For the first time on appeal, Metcalf argued that the mandatory-revocation provision in 18 U.S.C. § 3583(g) is unconstitutional under United States v. Haymond, 588 U.S. 634 (2019). She acknowledged, however, that United States v. Garner, 969 F.3d 550 (5th Cir. 2020), foreclosed her argument in the Fifth Circuit.
The Court’s Holding
The Fifth Circuit held that summary affirmance was proper because Garner foreclosed Metcalf’s constitutional challenge to § 3583(g). The court therefore did not revisit the merits of that binding circuit precedent.
The court granted the Government’s motion for summary affirmance and affirmed the district court’s judgment. It denied as moot the Government’s alternative request for additional time to file a brief.
Key Takeaways
- Fifth Circuit precedent forecloses an argument that § 3583(g) is unconstitutional under Haymond.
- The court resolved the appeal through summary affirmance because the controlling law left no substantial issue for further briefing.
- Metcalf’s six-month prison sentence and additional term of supervised release remain in place.
Why It Matters
The decision confirms that Garner continues to control constitutional challenges to mandatory supervised-release revocation under § 3583(g) in the Fifth Circuit. Unless that precedent is displaced by an en banc ruling or intervening Supreme Court authority, similarly situated defendants cannot obtain relief from a Fifth Circuit panel on the same theory.