Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
U.S. Bank brought the action against the alleged heirs of Samuel and Cynthia Woodley, alleging that the decedents executed a note and security interest concerning property at 3976 Avocado Drive in Dallas. According to the complaint, the loan went into default, U.S. Bank accelerated the debt, and the default remained uncured. The bank sought declaratory relief, enforcement of a statutory probate lien, and judicial and nonjudicial foreclosure.
After serving the other defendants, U.S. Bank moved for permission to serve Tariq Targton by publication. Its supporting materials included a private investigator’s report and three process-server affidavits describing unsuccessful attempts at addresses in Seagoville, Red Oak, and Arlington. Those materials indicated that Targton might be homeless and sometimes contacted his sister through Instagram, but they also contained conflicting information about where his sister lived and whether Targton lived with her.
The Court’s Holding
The court denied the motion without prejudice because U.S. Bank failed to submit an affidavit satisfying Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 109. That rule required a sworn statement addressing whether Targton’s residence was unknown or whether he was transient and establishing that the required parties had exercised due diligence but remained unable to locate him. Statements appearing only in the motion or an unsworn investigative report did not satisfy the rule.
The process-server affidavits merely recounted attempts at particular addresses and did not state that Targton’s residence was unknown to the relevant affiant, U.S. Bank, or its attorney, or that he was transient. The court also found inconsistencies between the affidavits and the investigator’s report that undermined the showing of due diligence. Because U.S. Bank did not provide the affidavit required for publication service, the court declined to authorize that method.
Key Takeaways
- A party seeking service by publication under Texas Rule 109 must establish the rule’s required facts in a sworn statement; assertions in a motion are insufficient.
- Affidavits describing unsuccessful service attempts must also address whether the defendant’s residence is unknown or the defendant is transient and must demonstrate due diligence.
- Conflicting evidence about a defendant’s possible residence can undermine a request for publication service, particularly because publication is generally inadequate when the defendant’s identity is known.
Why It Matters
The decision underscores that service by publication is not available merely because ordinary service attempts have failed. Litigants invoking Texas service procedures in federal court must strictly comply with the applicable affidavit requirements and present a consistent, sworn account of their efforts to locate the defendant.
The denial was without prejudice, leaving U.S. Bank free to renew its request with evidence that satisfies Rule 109.