Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Farmers and farming entities challenged eight USDA disaster-relief programs that provided larger payments or preferential treatment to “socially disadvantaged” farmers and ranchers—a classification that included specified racial groups and women. The plaintiffs alleged that, because they were white men or entities that did not satisfy the classification, they received less relief than similarly situated recipients who qualified by race or sex.
Only the Emergency Relief Program 2022 remained active when the court considered the plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction or relief under 5 U.S.C. § 705. ERP 2022 used progressive factoring, under which larger claimed losses received a lower reimbursement percentage, but it also gave “underserved” producers additional benefits, including crop-insurance premium and fee refunds and a payment increase. Because “underserved” included “socially disadvantaged” producers, those benefits partly depended on race and sex.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted preliminary relief in part. It concluded that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their Fifth Amendment equal-protection claims because ERP 2022 expressly afforded benefits based on race and sex. The USDA had not shown a compelling interest supported by evidence of specific, identified past discrimination for its racial classifications, and the classifications were not narrowly tailored because race-neutral alternatives were available and the policy was over- and under-inclusive. The sex-based classification likewise failed intermediate scrutiny because the USDA’s generalized remedial justification was insufficient and the classification was not substantially related to its stated objective.
The court rejected the plaintiffs’ separate arguments that progressive factoring itself was arbitrary and capricious or implicated the major-questions doctrine. It found that the USDA adequately explained progressive factoring as a way to distribute limited funds among more producers, that prior ad hoc relief formulas created no concrete reliance interest, and that the program did not involve the extraordinary assertion of agency power required by the major-questions doctrine.
Finding ongoing stigmatic and constitutional injury, a favorable balance of equities, and a public interest in preventing constitutional violations, the court enjoined the USDA—but only as to the plaintiffs—from making or increasing ERP 2022 payments or providing additional relief based on the “socially disadvantaged farmer or rancher” designation, whether used directly or through the broader “underserved” category. The USDA remained free to apply progressive factoring independently of race and sex.
Key Takeaways
- The injunction was plaintiff-specific and applied only to ERP 2022, the sole challenged program that remained active.
- The court found the race- and sex-based enhancements likely unconstitutional, but upheld progressive factoring itself against the plaintiffs’ APA and major-questions challenges at the preliminary-injunction stage.
- The court treated the ongoing denial of equal treatment and resulting stigmatic injury as irreparable harm even though the payment differences could be calculated in dollars.
Why It Matters
The decision limits USDA’s ability to use broad demographic classifications to allocate agricultural disaster relief without evidence tying the classifications to specific government discrimination and without considering workable race-neutral alternatives. It also illustrates that a court may preliminarily enjoin discriminatory components of a funding formula while leaving the formula’s neutral features intact.
The ruling did not finally resolve the merits or invalidate ERP 2022 nationwide. Its immediate effect was to require the USDA to administer future ERP 2022 relief to these plaintiffs without increasing or otherwise altering benefits based on race or sex.