Reported / Citable
Background
Mark R. Riley, a lawyer and accountant, formerly worked for the Alpert family and served as a trustee for trusts benefiting Roman Merker Alpert and Daniel James Alpert. After Riley disclosed financial and tax information to the Internal Revenue Service, the Alperts sued him. Following a jury trial, the district court entered a 2011 judgment against Riley for breaches of fiduciary duty, awarding the Alperts more than $831,000 before accrued interest.
Riley filed a Chapter 11 case in 2024, and the Alperts brought an adversary proceeding seeking to have the judgment declared nondischargeable. That bankruptcy case was later dismissed. Riley filed a new Chapter 11 case in April 2026 and initiated this adversary proceeding for a declaration that the judgment is dischargeable under 11 U.S.C. § 727 and not excepted from discharge under § 523(a)(2) or (4). The Alperts moved to withdraw the reference so the district court could hear the dispute.
The Court’s Holding
Chief Bankruptcy Judge Eduardo V. Rodriguez issued a report and recommendation advising the district court to deny the Alperts’ motion and leave the adversary proceeding in bankruptcy court. The court first concluded that withdrawal was not mandatory because resolution did not require substantial consideration of nonbankruptcy federal law and the equitable dischargeability dispute carried no Seventh Amendment jury-trial right.
Applying the Fifth Circuit’s six-factor test for permissive withdrawal, the court concluded that the Alperts had not shown cause. The dischargeability dispute was a core bankruptcy proceeding; the bankruptcy court’s involvement in the earlier adversary proceeding supported continuity; the timing and circumstances raised forum-shopping concerns; and bankruptcy-court expertise and familiarity favored economical and prompt resolution. The absence of a jury demand also weighed against withdrawal. If the district court rejected the recommendation, the bankruptcy court alternatively recommended that pretrial matters still be referred to Judge Rodriguez until the dispute was ready for trial.
Key Takeaways
- A dispute over whether a judgment debt is dischargeable under §§ 523 and 727 is a core bankruptcy matter that ordinarily favors retaining the reference.
- Prior bankruptcy-court involvement in a related adversary proceeding may support uniformity, efficiency, and continuity even when the current proceeding is relatively new.
- Because dischargeability proceedings are equitable and the Alperts made no jury demand, jury-trial considerations did not justify withdrawal.
Why It Matters
The recommendation illustrates the demanding showing required for permissive withdrawal under 28 U.S.C. § 157(d). A movant’s preference for a district judge familiar with the underlying civil judgment does not, without more, establish cause to remove a bankruptcy-specific dischargeability dispute from the bankruptcy court.
The decision is a report and recommendation, not a final district-court ruling on the withdrawal motion or a merits determination about whether Riley’s judgment debt will ultimately be discharged.