Reported / Citable
Background
Pro se plaintiff Nakissa Mirakhori sued the U.S. Department of Education and, in her amended complaint, added Sallie Mae Loan Servicer. Proceeding in forma pauperis, Mirakhori alleged misleading loan terms, unnecessary forbearance, deceptive practices, predatory lending, and unspecified antitrust violations.
The court had previously directed Mirakhori to amend because her original complaint did not clearly state a viable claim and appeared to rely on 18 U.S.C. § 242, a criminal statute. Her amended complaint cited § 242, provisions of the Texas Penal Code, and “anti trust laws,” and included attachments concerning prior enforcement matters involving Sallie Mae or Navient, her loan balance, and child-support arrears.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Jeffrey L. Cureton recommended dismissal with prejudice under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(2)(B) for failure to state a claim. The recommendation is not a final dismissal order; the parties were given until October 7, 2026, to file objections for review by the district judge.
The magistrate judge concluded that § 242 affords no private cause of action and that a private party lacks standing to sue under the Texas Penal Code. The Department of Education also generally has sovereign immunity absent an identified statutory waiver. As to the asserted antitrust theory, Mirakhori did not identify a particular statute or plead specific, nonconclusory facts showing how either defendant personally caused her harm. Because she had already received an opportunity to amend, the magistrate judge concluded that liberal construction could not cure the pleading.
Key Takeaways
- A criminal statute does not support a civil claim unless Congress created a private right of action.
- General references to antitrust law and alleged predatory practices do not satisfy federal pleading standards.
- The filing is a recommendation for dismissal with prejudice, subject to objections and district-court review.
Why It Matters
The recommendation underscores that pro se and in forma pauperis litigants must still identify an actionable legal theory and allege defendant-specific facts. Prior regulatory or enforcement matters involving a loan servicer do not, without more, establish the plaintiff’s own claim.