Reported / Citable
Background
Linda Marie Hunter and Patrick Scott Hunter divorced in Washington in 2017. Their divorce order awarded Linda $900 in monthly spousal maintenance through July 2027, along with unpaid maintenance and attorney’s fees. After Patrick moved to Texas, Linda filed the Washington judgment in Dallas County under Texas’s Uniform Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, asserting that Patrick owed $162,206.64.
Patrick participated in the Texas proceedings, obtained a transfer to family court, and moved to dismiss the domestication effort. After the family court denied that motion on September 23, 2024, he removed the proceeding to federal court on October 22, 2024. Linda moved to remand and requested attorney’s fees and costs incurred because of the removal.
The Court’s Holding
In findings, conclusions, and a recommendation—not a final remand order—Magistrate Judge Rebecca Rutherford recommended that the district judge remand the proceeding. The magistrate judge concluded that a UEFJA domestication proceeding likely is an enforcement mechanism rather than a removable “civil action” under 28 U.S.C. § 1441. The nature of the underlying judgment, which concerned divorce and spousal maintenance, also counseled against federal jurisdiction.
The magistrate judge further concluded that removal was untimely even if the proceeding was removable. Linda’s September 2023 filing disclosed an amount exceeding $75,000, but Patrick waited more than a year to remove. The state court’s later denial of his motion to dismiss was neither a voluntary act by Linda nor a changed circumstance that restarted the removal period. Patrick also failed to show that Linda acted in bad faith to prevent removal; his objections to her calculation and affidavit did not demonstrate manipulation of federal jurisdiction.
The magistrate judge nevertheless recommended denying Linda’s request for fees and costs under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c). Because the Fifth Circuit had not addressed whether UEFJA proceedings are removable and the relevant law remained unsettled, Patrick had an objectively reasonable basis for attempting removal.
Key Takeaways
- A proceeding that merely domesticates and enforces an existing foreign judgment likely is not a removable civil action under § 1441.
- The removal clock began when the state-court filing disclosed the claimed $162,206.64 amount, not when the state court later denied the defendant’s motion to dismiss.
- Disputes over accelerated maintenance payments or technical affidavit defects did not establish bad faith designed to prevent removal.
- Remand does not automatically justify fees; unsettled law may provide an objectively reasonable basis for removal.
Why It Matters
The recommendation treats UEFJA domestication as enforcement of an existing judgment rather than a new lawsuit that can be shifted into federal court. It also reinforces that defendants must act promptly when the initial state filing makes diversity jurisdiction ascertainable and cannot rely on an adverse state-court ruling to reopen the removal window.
Because this document is a magistrate judge’s recommendation, the district judge must still decide whether to adopt it. The recommendation therefore does not itself remand the case.