Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Hunter Marine Group v. Gonzalez — affirmed that the Limitation of Liability Act does not cover the Adalyn

Reported / Citable

Case
In the Matter of the Petition of M/V MS Adalyn, for Exoneration from or Limitation of Liability; Hunter Marine Group, L.L.C., as owner pro hac vice of the M/V MS Adalyn, and Michael Quain Neward Pittman, as owner of the M/V MS Adalyn v. Marin Gonzalez, et al.
Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Judge
Jennifer Walker Elrod (George W. Bush, 2007); Edith Brown Clement (George W. Bush, 2001); Andrew S. Oldham (Donald Trump, 2018)
Date Decided
August 14, 2026
Docket No.
25-20584
Topics
Maritime Law; Limitation of Liability; Passenger Vessels; Statutory Interpretation
Source
Read the full opinion

Background

Hunter Marine Group, L.L.C. chartered and operated the M/V MS Adalyn, a 38-foot aluminum-hulled commercial workboat weighing less than 100 gross tons, under an agreement with Encore Dredging Partners, LLC. Encore paid Hunter Marine a flat rate of $2,000 per day for equipment and services, including use of the Adalyn, and supplied fuel and charter hire.

While carrying eight Encore employees on the Alabama River in November 2024, the Adalyn encountered shallow water, ran aground, and struck a steel pipe. The employees reported injuries and filed state-court personal-injury actions. Hunter Marine and the vessel’s registered owner then sought protection under the Limitation of Liability Act. The district court entered summary judgment for the employees, holding that the Adalyn was a “covered small passenger vessel” excluded from the Act, and the owners appealed.

The Court’s Holding

The Fifth Circuit affirmed. It concluded that the statutory definition of “small passenger vessel” treats wing-in-ground craft and vessels of less than 100 gross tons as separate categories. Because the Adalyn weighed less than 100 gross tons, the court examined whether it carried more than six passengers, including at least one “passenger for hire,” as required by 46 U.S.C. § 2101(49)(A).

Reading the statutory definitions of “passenger” and “passenger for hire” together, the court held that a crewmember need not personally furnish the consideration for carriage. Consideration supplied by a third party may qualify because the statute recognizes consideration flowing directly or indirectly. Encore paid Hunter Marine to use the Adalyn, including to carry Encore employees; the claimants therefore indirectly provided consideration for their carriage and were passengers for hire. The Adalyn consequently qualified as a covered small passenger vessel, so the Limitation of Liability Act did not apply.

Key Takeaways

  • The statutory definition of “small passenger vessel” separately covers qualifying wing-in-ground craft and qualifying vessels of less than 100 gross tons.
  • A crewmember may be a passenger for hire when a third party contributes consideration as a condition of that person’s carriage; personal payment is not required.
  • Because the less-than-100-gross-ton Adalyn carried eight Encore employees for whose carriage Encore paid, it was a covered small passenger vessel excluded from the Limitation of Liability Act.

Why It Matters

The decision clarifies how the Fifth Circuit reads the interlocking statutory definitions of “passenger,” “passenger for hire,” and “small passenger vessel.” Courts must account for consideration furnished directly or indirectly and may not require the individual being carried to make a personal payment.

The holding is tied to the Act’s specific requirements: the Adalyn was a vessel of less than 100 gross tons, carried more than six passengers, included passengers for hire because Encore paid consideration for their carriage, and met the applicable covered-vessel criteria. The opinion does not establish that every vessel carrying more than six people falls outside the Act.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top