Reported / Citable
Background
Pro se plaintiff Charles Hess filed suit and applied to proceed in forma pauperis, seeking to litigate without prepaying the filing fee. The clerk advised Hess that his application was deficient because it lacked a copy of his prisoner trust-fund account statement.
After initially failing to provide the information, Hess submitted the statement in response to a court order. It showed a current account balance of $6,761, a six-month average balance of $7,025.19, and average monthly deposits of $86.67 during the six months before he filed suit.
The Court’s Holding
United States Magistrate Judge Mitchel Neurock recommended that the district court deny Hess’s in forma pauperis application. Although Hess stated under penalty of perjury that he could not pay the fee and reported no money in checking, savings, or prison accounts, his trust-fund statement showed sufficient available funds.
The magistrate judge concluded that Hess could afford the $405 filing fee in full. The recommendation would require Hess to pay that fee within 30 days after the district court adopts the recommendation and would warn that failure to do so will result in dismissal.
Key Takeaways
- This was a magistrate judge’s recommendation, not a final district-court ruling on the application.
- A prisoner’s trust-account balance can establish an ability to prepay the filing fee despite contrary statements in an IFP application.
- The parties had 14 days after service to file written objections to the recommendation.
Why It Matters
The recommendation illustrates that in forma pauperis status turns on the applicant’s actual financial resources, including funds held in a prison trust account. A substantial account balance may require full prepayment even when a litigant proceeds without counsel.