Reported / Citable
Background
GoSecure, Inc. sued CrowdStrike, Inc. and CrowdStrike Holdings, Inc. for infringing U.S. Patent No. 10,104,099, titled “System and method for monitoring a computer system using machine interpretable code.” The patent, issued October 16, 2018, relates to techniques for monitoring computer systems and distributing tools to detect malicious activities, including zero-day attacks. GoSecure alleged that CrowdStrike’s Falcon Platform—a widely-used endpoint protection tool that uses sensors in device memory and adjusts monitoring based on “Rapid Response Content”—directly infringes claim 1 of the patent. GoSecure initially asserted indirect infringement claims as well but withdrew those before the motion to dismiss was decided.
CrowdStrike filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that GoSecure failed to plausibly allege infringement. Specifically, CrowdStrike contended that GoSecure did not adequately allege the Accused Products satisfy material claim limitations such as “machine interpretable code” and “compiled instructions,” and did not plausibly allege direct infringement or willful infringement.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Susan Hightower recommended that the District Court deny CrowdStrike’s Motion to Dismiss. Applying the flexible pleading standard from Bot M8 LLC v. Sony Corp. of America, the court found that GoSecure plausibly alleged the Falcon Platform satisfies the material claim limitations at issue. The court rejected CrowdStrike’s argument that GoSecure failed to provide sufficient factual allegations, finding that disputed factual questions about how the software actually functions are inappropriate for resolution on a motion to dismiss and should proceed to discovery and summary judgment.
On direct infringement, the court held that GoSecure’s allegations that CrowdStrike uses the Falcon Platform to perform the claimed method constitute a plausible claim for relief at the pleading stage. On willful infringement, the court found GoSecure adequately pled the claim by alleging that CrowdStrike had knowledge of the ‘099 patent (at minimum from receiving the complaint) and deliberately continued its allegedly infringing conduct despite that knowledge.
Key Takeaways
- Patent plaintiffs must allege factual details showing the accused product plausibly meets claim limitations; merely reciting claim elements and concluding infringement is insufficient under modern pleading standards.
- Detailed factual disputes about whether software actually practices a claimed method are inappropriate for resolution on a motion to dismiss and belong at the discovery and summary judgment stages.
- Willful infringement can be adequately alleged at the pleading stage by showing the defendant knew of the patent and intentionally continued infringing conduct.
Why It Matters
This ruling allows GoSecure’s case to proceed to discovery and potential summary judgment, keeping alive a patent challenge to one of the cybersecurity industry’s most prominent endpoint detection and response platforms. For patent holders suing technology companies, the decision confirms that complex software disputes can survive early dismissal motions based on reasonable allegations about functionality, without requiring detailed proof at the pleading stage.
For CrowdStrike and similar technology defendants, the case demonstrates that motions to dismiss in software patent cases face an uphill battle under current pleading standards. The ruling suggests that willful infringement claims will proceed when defendants continue challenged conduct after receiving notice of a patent, potentially exposing CrowdStrike to enhanced damages if the merits ultimately favor GoSecure.