Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Degollado v. City of Port Lavaca — Fifth Circuit upheld dismissal of smoke-shop plaintiffs’ civil-rights claims

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Alexandra Degollado; Faded Smoke Shop, L.L.C.; Daniel Herrera, Jr. v. City of Port Lavaca, Texas; Collin Rangnow, in his official capacity as Chief of Police for Port Lavaca, Texas; Kyle Curtis, in his official and individual capacities; Karen Neal, in her official and individual capacities; Adam Beard, in his official and individual capacities; Javier Ramos, in his official and individual capacities; Maxwell Duke, in his official and individual capacities; Maria Moreno, in her official and individual capacities; Devon Moore, in his official and individual capacities; Eric Salles, in his official and individual capacities; Justin Klare, in his official and individual capacities
Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Judge
Richman; Duncan; Oldham
Date Decided
August 18, 2026
Docket No.
25-40206
Topics
Qualified Immunity; Search Warrants; Municipal Liability; Malicious Prosecution
Source
Read the full opinion

Background

Alexandra Degollado opened Faded Smoke Shop, L.L.C., in Port Lavaca, Texas, selling products that the plaintiffs alleged were lawful, including delta-8 THC products and hemp containing no more than 0.3% delta-9 THC. Daniel Herrera, Jr. worked at the shop. After controlled purchases, Corporal Kyle Curtis obtained laboratory results stating that tested gummies contained THC and submitted an affidavit seeking warrants to search the shop and arrest Degollado and Herrera.

The plaintiffs alleged that Curtis’s affidavit inaccurately characterized the laboratory results as confirming a controlled substance in Texas Penalty Group 2, even though the testing did not identify the THC type or concentration. Officers executed the warrants, seized products, and arrested Degollado; Herrera’s parole was revoked following his arrest. Later testing found delta-8 THC in all tested seized products. Degollado and Herrera were indicted, but the district attorney eventually dismissed the prosecutions because officers were unavailable to testify due to a credibility issue.

Degollado, Herrera, and Faded Smoke Shop sued Curtis, other Port Lavaca officers, the police chief, and the city under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, also pleading malicious prosecution under Texas law. The district court dismissed all claims with prejudice, and the plaintiffs appealed.

The Court’s Holding

The Fifth Circuit affirmed. The officers accused of failing to intervene were entitled to qualified immunity because the plaintiffs identified no clearly established law requiring them to intervene in the warrant-authorized search and seizure. The complaint also alleged that Curtis—not the other officers—prepared the challenged warrant affidavit.

Curtis was likewise entitled to qualified immunity. Although the complaint plausibly alleged that his statement about the laboratory results was inaccurate because the results established only the presence of THC, the plaintiffs did not sufficiently allege that he acted knowingly, intentionally, or with reckless disregard for the truth as required by Franks v. Delaware. The court concluded that Curtis could reasonably have understood the ambiguous laboratory response to indicate an illegal substance; assuming illegality may have been negligent, but the allegations did not establish recklessness, particularly given uncertainty surrounding the legality of THC variants.

The municipal failure-to-train claim failed because the plaintiffs alleged neither a pattern of similar constitutional violations nor facts sufficient for the narrow single-incident exception. The court also held that the pleaded state-law malicious-prosecution claim was barred by governmental immunity under the Texas Tort Claims Act because malicious prosecution is an intentional tort. Any federal malicious-prosecution theory and any claim based on retaining property after dismissal of the criminal cases were forfeited because they were not raised in the district court.

Key Takeaways

  • An inaccurate statement in a warrant affidavit does not establish a Franks violation without sufficient allegations that the affiant acted knowingly, intentionally, or recklessly rather than negligently.
  • Officers executing a warrant were entitled to qualified immunity where the plaintiffs identified no clearly established duty to intervene and alleged that another officer alone prepared the affidavit.
  • A municipal failure-to-train claim ordinarily requires a pattern of similar constitutional violations; conclusory allegations about one incident did not satisfy the Fifth Circuit’s demanding single-incident exception.

Why It Matters

The decision illustrates the demanding pleading burden for overcoming qualified immunity in a warrant-affidavit case. Even though the laboratory results did not establish the THC type or concentration and the affidavit inaccurately described them as confirming a Penalty Group 2 substance, the Franks claim failed because the allegations did not plausibly show the required culpable state of mind.

The opinion also underscores the importance of clearly identifying each theory in the district-court pleadings. The plaintiffs could not recast their Texas malicious-prosecution claim as a federal claim on appeal or add a new constitutional theory concerning the continued retention of seized products.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top