Reported / Citable
Background
Eduard Yepes Cartagena sued Karel Perez and Uber Technologies, Inc. in Texas state court over a December 2024 automobile collision. Cartagena, a Texas citizen, alleged that Perez, an Uber driver and Florida resident, struck his vehicle. The petition sought more than $75,000 and described Uber only as a corporation “organized doing business in Texas.”
Uber was served and later amended its answer, attaching an agreement stating that Uber is “in California.” Perez was served on May 6, 2026, answered on May 28, and Cartagena nonsuited Uber on June 2. Perez removed the case on June 29 based on diversity jurisdiction. Cartagena moved to remand, arguing that removal came too late.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Dena Hanovice Palermo recommended denying the remand motion. The original petition did not affirmatively reveal Uber’s citizenship because it omitted both Uber’s state of incorporation and principal place of business. It therefore did not start the initial 30-day removal clock.
The magistrate judge concluded that Uber’s amended answer could not serve as the triggering “other paper” because it was not a voluntary act by Cartagena. In any event, Perez’s counsel did not appear until May 28, making the June 29 removal timely even under that alternative calculation because the thirtieth day fell on a Saturday. Cartagena’s June 2 notice nonsuiting Uber independently constituted a plaintiff-generated “other paper” showing that the case had become removable, and Perez removed within 30 days.
Key Takeaways
- A petition’s vague allegation that a corporation does business in a state does not establish its citizenship for diversity purposes.
- A removal deadline based on an “other paper” runs from the removing defendant’s receipt of that paper, not merely its filing date.
- A plaintiff’s nonsuit of a nondiverse defendant may trigger a new 30-day removal period.
Why It Matters
The recommendation underscores that corporate citizenship requires allegations of both incorporation and principal place of business. Pleading omissions can prevent an initial petition from making removability ascertainable.
It also illustrates the voluntary-act rule: a plaintiff’s nonsuit can make a case removable, while another defendant’s filing generally cannot supply the requisite plaintiff-created change in circumstances.