Reported / Citable
Background
Pro se plaintiff Henry B. Berrocal moved for certification of judicial impartiality and transfer of venue, supported by a supplemental affidavit. He said he had filed similar motions in six cases pending in the San Antonio Division of the Western District of Texas.
Berrocal alleged that judges in the San Antonio Division and the Western District of Texas were biased against him and asked to move the case, preferably to New York, Washington, D.C., or California. He cited adverse orders and recommendations, alleged ethnic discrimination in the court’s direction that he amend his pleadings, and pointed to judges’ purported social or personal ties with law-enforcement officers and Texas officials.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Henry J. Bemporad construed the venue-transfer motion as a request for recusal under 28 U.S.C. § 455(a), because Berrocal based the requested transfer on alleged judicial bias. The magistrate judge recommended that the district court deny the motion.
Under § 455(a), recusal turns on whether a well-informed, thoughtful, and objective observer would reasonably question the judge’s impartiality. Berrocal’s disagreement with prior judicial rulings did not establish bias; such rulings are ordinarily matters for appeal, not recusal. His generalized assertions about judges’ friendships or attendance at social and ceremonial events with law-enforcement officers likewise did not show a legitimate basis to recuse either the magistrate judge or the district court.
Key Takeaways
- A request to transfer venue based on alleged judicial bias may be treated as a recusal motion under § 455(a).
- Adverse judicial rulings, without more, almost never establish disqualifying bias.
- General allegations of judges’ relationships with parties, counsel, or public officials are insufficient to require recusal.
Why It Matters
The recommendation reinforces the objective standard governing judicial-recusal requests and the high bar for converting dissatisfaction with case-management or merits rulings into a claim of partiality.
Because this was a report and recommendation, the parties had 14 days to file specific written objections, subject to the consequences described in the order for failing to do so.