Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Breach of Contract

Texas 7th Court of Appeals, Breach of Contract, Civil Procedure, Construction Law

Martignoni v. Artistry Homes — Homebuyers Lose Summary Judgment Fight After Failing to Preserve Evidentiary Objections

The Seventh Court of Appeals affirmed no-evidence summary judgment against homebuyers who contracted for a $600,000 custom home, holding that their failure to respond to the builder’s evidentiary objections in the trial court forfeited those challenges on appeal under the preservation rule — leaving them without sufficient evidence to withstand summary judgment on any claim.

Texas 15th Court of Appeals, Breach of Contract

Elite Concepts v. Field — “Repair” Clause in Pool Construction Contract Encompasses Cost to Complete; Contractor Who Walks Off Job Cannot Claim Attorney’s Fees as Prevailing Party

The Fifteenth Court of Appeals held that a pool construction contract’s limitation of remedy to “repair” encompasses cost-to-complete damages as well as cost-to-repair, because construing “repair” to exclude unfinished work would render the contractor’s promise illusory; it also held that a contractor whose quantum meruit recovery is offset by the owner’s larger breach-of-contract damages award is not a “prevailing party” entitled to Chapter 38 attorney’s fees.

Breach of Contract, Construction Law, Contract Interpretation

Blackmon Mooring v. St. Edward’s University — Third Court Reverses Summary Judgment, Holds Parol Evidence Cannot Transform Cost Estimate into Price Cap

The Third Court of Appeals reversed summary judgment for St. Edward's University, holding that the parol evidence rule prohibited using pre-contract negotiations to transform a cost-plus contract's 'estimated budgetary price' into a guaranteed maximum price.

Scroll to Top