Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

McAferty v. Musk — court lets petition-signers’ fraud and contract claims proceed

Reported / Citable

Case
Jacqueline McAferty v. Elon Musk and America PAC
Court
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas
Judge
Robert Pitman
Date Decided
August 20, 2025
Docket No.
1:24-cv-01346-RP
Topics
Fraud; Contract; Political advertising; Data privacy

Background

Jacqueline McAferty brought a proposed class action against Elon Musk and America PAC over the PAC’s October 2024 petition supporting the First and Second Amendments. Petition signers supplied identifying and contact information, and America PAC promoted a $1 million daily award for people who signed it. Musk and America PAC publicly described the awards as random and said signers had a chance to win.

McAferty, an Arizona resident, alleged that she signed the petition and provided her personal information in reliance on those representations. She alleged that the recipients were instead selected as prospective America PAC spokespeople based on their personal stories, meaning signers did not actually have a random chance to receive $1 million. She asserted fraud, breach of contract, a Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act claim, and requested destruction of class members’ information.

The Court’s Holding

Judge Robert Pitman granted the dismissal motion only as to the DTPA claim, which McAferty agreed to dismiss. The court denied the motion as to fraud, breach of contract, and the request for injunctive relief.

The court held that McAferty plausibly alleged Article III injury because she provided valuable personal information in exchange for a purported random chance to win $1 million and allegedly did not receive that benefit. Her information could plausibly have value to a political committee seeking verified swing-state voter contact information, particularly where America PAC separately offered $47 for each referred registered voter who signed the petition.

The complaint also adequately alleged fraud with the required specificity and plausibly alleged that representations about random selection were false, material, and relied upon. It plausibly alleged a contract based on the parties’ objective communications: America PAC offered a random chance to win, and McAferty accepted by signing and providing her information. Whether the selection process was actually random and whether McAferty’s reliance was justified are issues for later stages.

Key Takeaways

  • Personal identifying information can constitute a concrete economic injury when allegedly exchanged for a promised benefit that was not provided.
  • Public statements describing recipients as randomly selected may support fraud claims when recipients were allegedly preselected for spokesperson roles.
  • A plaintiff may plausibly plead contract damages through the value of information supplied in reliance on an alleged agreement.

Why It Matters

The decision allows a novel consumer-style challenge to a political committee’s petition promotion to proceed beyond the pleading stage. It also distinguishes data-breach cases by treating the alleged injury as a lost bargain in a direct transaction, rather than merely a future diminution in the value of exposed information.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top