Reported / Citable
Background
Zenith Surgery Center and Sonazo Anesthesia provided treatment in 2020 to two beneficiaries of Anadarko Petroleum’s employee health-benefits plan. Before treatment, Zenith says it called the plan’s claims administrator, United, to verify coverage but was not told of the plan’s anti-assignment provision or given plan documents. The patients assigned benefits to Zenith, and the providers submitted roughly $1.4 million in reimbursement claims.
The providers allege that claims were denied or underpaid after extended processing. They sued Occidental and Anadarko, asserting ERISA claims for benefits and fiduciary breach, plus Texas-law claims for contract, promissory estoppel, and quantum meruit. Defendants sought summary judgment, relying on the plan’s anti-assignment clause, duplicativeness of the ERISA claims, and ERISA preemption.
The Court’s Holding
Judge Rosenthal denied summary judgment on the ERISA benefits claim insofar as defendants relied on the anti-assignment clause. Applying the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Angelina Emergency Medicine Associates, the court held that material factual disputes remain over whether defendants are estopped from enforcing that clause. The assignments were made before treatment, the clause was not raised until years into the providers’ payment efforts, and the limited jurisdictional-discovery record did not establish what the providers or claims administrator knew or should have known.
The court granted summary judgment on the ERISA fiduciary-duty claim under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3). Its essence was the alleged failure to pay plan benefits, for which § 1132(a)(1)(B) provides an adequate remedy. The court also denied summary judgment on the state-law claims in full. Claims premised on improper plan administration are preempted, but claims based on alleged independent pre-service misrepresentations about coverage and reimbursement may proceed on the current record.
Key Takeaways
- An anti-assignment clause does not warrant summary judgment when material facts remain about Hermann estoppel.
- A provider cannot simultaneously pursue duplicative ERISA benefits and fiduciary-duty claims based on the same unpaid benefits.
- Provider claims based on independent coverage or reimbursement representations may escape ERISA preemption.
Why It Matters
The ruling underscores that insurers and plan sponsors may not be able to invoke an anti-assignment clause at the summary-judgment stage when providers allegedly sought payment for years without disclosure of the restriction. The decision also preserves the Fifth Circuit distinction between derivative claims for plan benefits and direct claims arising from alleged pre-service representations to providers.