Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Holberg v. Guerrero — equally divided en banc court affirmed denial of death-row habeas relief

Reported / Citable

Case
Brittany Marlowe Holberg v. Eric Guerrero, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division
Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Judge
Jennifer Walker Elrod (George W. Bush, 2007); Patrick E. Higginbotham (Ronald Reagan, 1982); Edith H. Jones (Ronald Reagan, 1985); Jerry E. Smith (Ronald Reagan, 1987); Carl E. Stewart (Bill Clinton, 1994); Priscilla Richman (George W. Bush, 2005); Leslie H. Southwick (George W. Bush, 2007); Catharina Haynes (George W. Bush, 2008); James E. Graves Jr. (Barack Obama, 2011); Stephen A. Higginson (Barack Obama, 2011); Don R. Willett (Donald J. Trump, 2017); James C. Ho (Donald Trump, 2017); Stuart Kyle Duncan (Donald Trump, 2018); Kurt D. Engelhardt (Donald Trump, 2018); Andrew S. Oldham (Donald Trump, 2018); Cory T. Wilson (Donald Trump, 2020); Dana M. Douglas (Joseph R. Biden Jr., 2022); Irma Carrillo Ramirez (Joe Biden, 2023)
Date Decided
August 14, 2026
Docket No.
21-70010
Topics
Federal Habeas Corpus; Brady Disclosure; AEDPA; Death Penalty
Source
Read the full opinion

Background

A Texas jury convicted Brittany Marlowe Holberg of capital murder and sentenced her to death for killing 80-year-old A.B. Towery. Holberg admitted killing Towery but maintained that she acted in self-defense. At trial, jailhouse witness Vicki Kirkpatrick testified that Holberg confessed to enjoying the killing and said she would kill again to obtain drugs or drug money.

After unsuccessfully pursuing direct review and state postconviction relief, Holberg sought federal habeas relief. She alleged, among other things, that prosecutors violated Brady v. Maryland by failing to disclose information about Kirkpatrick’s compensated work as a police informant in unrelated cases and that trial counsel inadequately investigated mitigating evidence. The district court denied relief, but a divided Fifth Circuit panel found a Brady violation and vacated Holberg’s conviction and sentence. The Fifth Circuit then granted rehearing en banc, vacating the panel decision.

The Court’s Holding

The en banc Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment by an equally divided vote. As a result, the denial of Holberg’s federal habeas petition stands, and the earlier panel ruling granting relief no longer controls.

Because the en banc court was evenly divided, it produced no majority rationale and established no binding circuit precedent resolving the disputed Brady and AEDPA questions. One group of judges concluded that AEDPA barred relief because fairminded jurists could find the informant evidence immaterial, while dissenting judges maintained that suppressing evidence of Kirkpatrick’s compensated relationship with law enforcement undermined confidence in the capital-murder verdict.

Key Takeaways

  • An equally divided en banc court affirmed the district court’s denial of habeas relief without creating binding precedent on the underlying legal issues.
  • The divided panel decision that had vacated Holberg’s conviction and death sentence was displaced when rehearing en banc was granted.
  • The central dispute concerned whether the state court reasonably rejected Holberg’s Brady claim under AEDPA’s highly deferential standard.

Why It Matters

The judgment leaves Holberg’s capital conviction and death sentence intact while providing no controlling Fifth Circuit rule on when prosecutors must disclose a witness’s compensated informant work in unrelated investigations.

The case also illustrates the practical force of AEDPA: even judges who might disagree with a state court’s constitutional analysis cannot grant federal habeas relief unless the state decision crosses AEDPA’s demanding threshold.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top