Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

United States v. Butler — Fifth Circuit upheld an above-guidelines 92-month firearm sentence

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
United States of America v. Jarmar Butler
Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Judge
Haynes (George W. Bush, 2008); Graves (Barack Obama, 2011); Ramirez (Joe Biden, 2023)
Date Decided
August 14, 2026
Docket No.
25-30629
Topics
Federal Sentencing; Firearm Offenses; Upward Variance; Plain Error
Source
Read the full opinion

Background

Jarmar Butler pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm or ammunition as a convicted felon. The district court varied upward from the advisory guidelines range and sentenced him to 92 months in prison.

On appeal, Butler challenged the application of a base offense level under U.S.S.G. § 2K2.1(a)(4)(B), arguing that the record did not establish that he possessed a semiautomatic firearm capable of accepting a large-capacity magazine. He also argued that the upward variance was substantively unreasonable. In an opposed motion to file a supplemental brief, Butler sought to raise a new challenge to the district court’s reliance on guideline commentary when applying an adjustment under § 2K2.1(b)(6)(B).

The Court’s Holding

The Fifth Circuit affirmed. Assuming without deciding that the district court clearly or obviously erred in applying § 2K2.1(a)(4)(B), the court held that Butler failed to show that the asserted error affected his substantial rights. The district court had explained that the § 3553(a) factors independently supported the 92-month sentence and stated that the sentence was proper regardless of the guidelines calculation.

The court also held that the sentence was not substantively unreasonable. The district court made an individualized assessment, properly found that Butler’s criminal history was underrepresented, and relied on his prior criminal conduct and the relevant conduct in the case. The record did not support Butler’s assertion that the upward variance rested on a finding that the firearm could accept a large-capacity magazine, and the variance was not disproportionately large under the totality of the circumstances.

Finally, the court denied Butler’s motion to file a supplemental brief. Because he had not raised the proposed guideline-commentary argument in his opening brief and had not shown extraordinary circumstances, the argument was waived.

Key Takeaways

  • An assumed guidelines-calculation error does not warrant relief under plain-error review when the defendant cannot show a reasonable probability of a different sentence.
  • A district court’s statement that the same sentence is warranted independently under § 3553(a) can establish that the sentence did not depend on the challenged guidelines calculation.
  • An upward variance may rest on an underrepresented criminal history and case-specific conduct, while arguments omitted from the opening appellate brief generally cannot be introduced through a supplemental brief absent extraordinary circumstances.

Why It Matters

The decision illustrates the importance of a district court clearly explaining the independent § 3553(a) grounds for its chosen sentence. Such an explanation may preserve a sentence even when the appellate court assumes that the guidelines calculation contained a clear or obvious error.

It also underscores two appellate limits: substantive-reasonableness review examines the totality of the circumstances, and defendants generally must present all intended arguments in their opening brief.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top