Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Salamah — Court dismissed former medical student’s claims but allowed her to amend

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Meera Salamah v. UT Southwestern Health Systems, Angela Mihalic, M.D., and Kevin Klein, M.D.
Court
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas
Judge
Sidney A. Fitzwater
Date Decided
October 29, 2024
Docket No.
3:24-cv-00477-D
Topics
Disability Discrimination; Due Process; Sovereign Immunity; Standing

Background

Meera Salamah, a lung-transplant recipient who has major depressive disorder, entered UT Southwestern’s medical program in 2020. Beginning in February 2022, she repeatedly sought medical leave because of transplant complications and mental-health issues. The school initially granted deferrals and later a seven-month medical leave, but continued to require her to pass the United States Medical Licensing Examination STEP examination before resuming her studies.

Salamah alleged that UT Southwestern repeatedly changed her examination deadlines, including shortening a previously stated June 2023 deadline to February 24, 2023. The school dismissed her in March 2023 for failing to complete the examination. She sued UT Southwestern and two administrators under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for denial of due process and under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act and § 504 of the Rehabilitation Act for disability discrimination.

The Court’s Holding

The court dismissed the § 1983 claim against UT Southwestern for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction because the institution is an arm of Texas entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity, which had not been waived or abrogated. It also dismissed the § 1983 claim against Drs. Angela Mihalic and Kevin Klein for lack of Article III standing. Salamah sought reinstatement, but her allegations did not establish that either official had authority to reinstate her or otherwise redress her injuries.

The court dismissed the ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims under Rule 12(b)(6). Although Salamah plausibly alleged a disability and exclusion on the basis of that disability, she did not plead sufficient facts showing that she was otherwise qualified for the medical program—with or without a reasonable accommodation. Her statements that she had experienced no academic-performance issues and was now able to return were conclusory and did not show that she could satisfy the program’s essential requirements if the examination requirement were eliminated or modified. The court nevertheless allowed her 28 days to file a second amended complaint because the pleading defects were not necessarily incurable.

Key Takeaways

  • Eleventh Amendment immunity barred the § 1983 claim against UT Southwestern as an arm of the State of Texas.
  • A plaintiff seeking reinstatement from individual officials must plausibly allege that those officials have authority to provide that relief.
  • An educational disability-discrimination claim must include facts showing that the student can satisfy the program’s essential requirements, with or without a reasonable accommodation.

Why It Matters

The decision illustrates the distinct pleading barriers facing students who challenge dismissal from a public university: sovereign immunity may foreclose constitutional claims against the institution, standing requires a connection between the requested remedy and each individual defendant’s authority, and disability claims require concrete allegations that the student is otherwise qualified.

The dismissal was not a final merits determination. By granting leave to amend, the court gave Salamah an opportunity to identify officials capable of providing reinstatement and to plead additional facts concerning her ability to meet the medical program’s essential requirements with a reasonable accommodation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top