Reported / Citable
Background
Joshua G. Crampton sued Harper Property Management Inc., Jon and Carly Montez, and Rudy Montez in Texas state court over a residential lease. He alleged that the property suffered significant water damage, that the defendants ignored maintenance requests, and that they later obtained an eviction judgment and referred the resulting debt to a collection agency. His amended petition asserted state-law claims and a claim under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.
Harper Property removed the case based solely on diversity jurisdiction, alleging that Crampton was a Utah citizen, all defendants were Texas citizens, and the amount in controversy exceeded $75,000. Crampton moved to remand, arguing among other things that removal violated the forum-defendant rule, and requested costs and expenses arising from the removal.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Elizabeth S. Chestney recommended granting the remand motion in part and returning the case to County Court at Law No. 10 of Bexar County. Although the state-court record contained no returns or waivers of service, Harper Property and Jon and Carly Montez had filed answers in state court without objecting to service. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 121, those answers constituted appearances dispensing with formal service, so the defendants were properly served for purposes of the removal statute.
Because properly served defendants were citizens of Texas, the state where the action was filed, the forum-defendant rule barred diversity-based removal. The magistrate judge therefore found it unnecessary to decide Crampton’s other remand arguments, including whether complete diversity existed. She also recommended denying fees and costs because Crampton was proceeding pro se and a nonlawyer pro se litigant is not entitled to attorney fees under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c).
Key Takeaways
- A defendant’s state-court answer without an objection to service may constitute proper service under Texas law for purposes of the federal removal statute.
- The forum-defendant rule barred diversity removal because properly served defendants were Texas citizens and the action was filed in Texas.
- The recommendation would remand the case but deny the pro se plaintiff’s request for fees and costs.
Why It Matters
The recommendation underscores that defendants cannot avoid the forum-defendant rule merely because the docket lacks a formal return of service. In Texas, an answer filed without challenging service can amount to an appearance that dispenses with formal service and triggers the rule’s protection against removal by an in-state defendant.
The decision is a report and recommendation, not a final remand order. The assigned district judge must review any timely objections and decide whether to adopt it.