Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Cloud Byte v. Dell — Court denied Dell’s motion to compel patent-transfer and licensing discovery

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Cloud Byte LLC v. Dell Inc. and Dell Technologies Inc.
Court
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas
Judge
Rodney Gilstrap
Date Decided
March 28, 2025
Docket No.
2:24-cv-00637-JRG
Topics
Patent Litigation; Discovery; Third-Party Documents; Licensing

Background

Cloud Byte LLC acquired the asserted patents from IP Wave Pte. Ltd., which had acquired them from NEC Asia Pacific Corporation after NEC Asia obtained them from NEC Corporation. Dell Inc. and Dell Technologies Inc. moved to compel Cloud Byte to produce agreements and licensing information held by IP Wave, the NEC entities, or Cloud Byte’s counsel, Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP.

Dell also sought an unredacted version of the IP Wave–Cloud Byte agreement. Cloud Byte said the redacted material was a “whitelist” of unlicensed potential future defendants and argued that it was protected work product and irrelevant. After Cloud Byte opposed the motion to compel, Dell separately sought leave to file a reply based on correspondence with NEC that Dell said contradicted Cloud Byte’s opposition.

The Court’s Holding

The court denied the motion to compel. It found no showing that Cloud Byte possessed, had custody of, or controlled agreements and licensing information held by nonparties IP Wave or NEC. Cloud Byte’s ability to ask those entities for documents, their alleged financial interest in the litigation, and a cooperation provision intended to perfect the patent chain of title did not establish control. Dell could pursue such material through third-party subpoenas.

The court also declined to compel materials held by Quinn because the firm had agreed to produce responsive materials that Cloud Byte had a legal right to obtain from its representation in this case, rendering that request moot; materials held through Quinn’s representation of other clients potentially implicated attorney-client privilege. The court further held that the whitelist need not be produced because it was analogous to an unconsummated license and therefore was not discoverable. Finally, the court denied Dell leave to file a reply because no reply was necessary.

Key Takeaways

  • A party’s practical ability to request documents from a nonparty does not, without more, establish possession, custody, or control for discovery purposes.
  • A patent seller’s financial interest and a chain-of-title cooperation clause did not give the buyer control over the seller’s agreements with prior owners.
  • A list of unlicensed potential defendants was treated like an unconsummated license and held not discoverable.

Why It Matters

The order draws a clear boundary between a litigant’s own discovery obligations and discovery directed at nonparties in a patent-ownership chain. Parties seeking prior assignment or licensing agreements must establish that their opponent actually controls the material or use third-party subpoena procedures.

The decision also indicates that preliminary licensing targets may receive treatment similar to unconsummated licensing negotiations, limiting discovery into internal lists of potential defendants. Cloud Byte nevertheless remained obligated to produce any relevant licenses or other information actually within its possession, custody, or control.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top