Reported / Citable
Background
Maxwell Jones sued Pentagon Federal Credit Union on January 6, 2026. PenFed timely answered the original complaint, participated in the parties’ case-management filings and initial scheduling conference, and later filed other motions in the case.
Jones filed a first amended complaint on May 1, 2026, within the deadline for amendment without leave. PenFed did not answer the amended complaint within the 14 days prescribed by Rule 15(a)(3). Jones then sought entry of default. PenFed opposed that request and moved for leave to file its answer late, explaining that it had inadvertently misread the scheduling order.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Peter Bray granted PenFed leave to file its answer out of time, finding excusable neglect under Rule 6(b). The Clerk was directed to file PenFed’s proposed answer as its answer to the first amended complaint. The judge also denied Jones’s motion to strike PenFed’s opposition to the default request because the opposition was timely and proper.
The magistrate judge recommended denying Jones’s request for entry of default. Although PenFed missed the deadline to respond to the amended complaint, it had already answered the lawsuit, actively participated in the case, sought leave to cure the late response, and filed a dispositive motion. With the docket call still scheduled for April 2027, default would be unduly harsh, any prejudice to Jones could be addressed through court orders, and the court would likely later set default aside. PenFed’s summary-judgment motion remained pending, and the recommendation was subject to objections.
Key Takeaways
- A late answer to an amended complaint may be permitted when the failure resulted from excusable neglect.
- Default is disfavored where the defendant has otherwise actively litigated the case and promptly seeks to cure a missed deadline.
- This was a magistrate judge’s recommendation to deny default, not a final ruling on the merits or on PenFed’s summary-judgment motion.
Why It Matters
The recommendation underscores that a missed Rule 15(a)(3) deadline alone will not ordinarily justify default against a defendant that has appeared and remains actively engaged in the litigation. Courts will weigh prejudice, the reason for the delay, the harshness of default, and whether a default would likely be vacated.