Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Infosys Limited sought leave to take seven nonparty depositions that it had noticed but not completed before the May 11, 2026 fact-discovery deadline. It also requested permission to take depositions relating to any nonparty declarations that Cognizant obtained later in the litigation. Infosys filed its motion on May 18, one week after discovery closed.
Infosys argued that it had diligently pursued the depositions, pointing to subpoenas, communications with nonparties, delays in obtaining documents, a 60-day stay for mediation, and Cognizant’s alleged reversal of an earlier willingness to permit depositions after the deadline. Both sides also moved to provisionally seal portions of their briefing and supporting materials.
The Court’s Holding
The court denied Infosys’s motion for additional discovery because Infosys failed to establish good cause under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16(b)(4). Although some subpoenas had been served more than a year before discovery closed, Infosys did not adequately explain why the depositions remained unfinished or why it waited until after the deadline to seek an extension.
The court found that ordinary difficulties associated with nonparty discovery, the 60-day stay, and Cognizant’s alleged change in position did not excuse Infosys’s lack of diligence. Because diligence is required to modify a scheduling order, an extension was unwarranted. The court separately granted both parties’ motions to provisionally seal the identified filings until it could rule on any motions seeking continued sealing.
Key Takeaways
- A party seeking to modify a discovery deadline must show that it could not reasonably meet the deadline despite diligent efforts.
- Routine complications in nonparty discovery do not excuse delay when counsel had ample time to anticipate and address them.
- A party should seek an extension before discovery closes rather than rely on an adversary’s informal agreement to complete depositions later.
Why It Matters
The decision underscores that serving subpoenas early is not, by itself, enough to demonstrate diligence. Litigants must actively pursue compliance, complete depositions within the scheduling order, and promptly ask the court for relief when timely completion becomes doubtful.
It also illustrates that an opposing party’s alleged obstruction or change of position will not necessarily cure the movant’s own failure to act diligently, particularly when the court has already extended deadlines and warned that further delays are unlikely.