Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Wuxi Gougelila — Magistrate judge recommended default judgment but rejected gross-revenue damages

Reported / Citable

Case
Wuxi Gougelila Electronic Commerce Co., Ltd. v. The Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule A, Heze Kylin International Trade Co., Ltd., and Qingdao Zhaoruyuan E-Commerce Co., Ltd.
Court
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, El Paso Division
Judge
Anne T. Berton
Date Decided
September 14, 2026
Docket No.
EP-25-CV-00392-KC
Topics
Design patents; Default judgment; Personal jurisdiction; Permanent injunction

Background

Wuxi Gougelila Electronic Commerce Co. owns a design patent for a pet playpen and sued 36 China-based online sellers, alleging that they sold infringing playpens through marketplaces including Amazon. After Wuxi dismissed the other defendants, Qingdao Zhaoruyuan E-Commerce Co. remained.

Zhaoruyuan appeared through counsel, opposed preliminary injunctive relief, and moved to sever, but did not raise service or personal-jurisdiction objections. Its attorneys later withdrew; despite an order and warning to obtain replacement counsel, the corporate defendant did not do so. The Clerk entered default after the district judge found Zhaoruyuan in default.

The Court’s Holding

Magistrate Judge Anne T. Berton recommended granting default judgment in part. Zhaoruyuan waived objections to service and personal jurisdiction through its litigation conduct, and its Amazon sales directed at Texas independently supported specific personal jurisdiction. The well-pleaded allegations and the court’s comparison of the products with the patent supported design-patent infringement.

The magistrate judge recommended denying without prejudice Wuxi’s request for $62,966.82 because that figure was Zhaoruyuan’s gross revenue, not evidence of its “total profit” recoverable under 35 U.S.C. § 289. Wuxi could submit competent evidence of a typical pet-playpen profit margin; without it, the court indicated that the statutory minimum of $250 might be appropriate. The judge recommended granting permanent injunctive relief, with any release of restrained marketplace funds limited to the ultimately awarded monetary judgment.

Key Takeaways

  • A corporation that disregards an order to retain replacement counsel may be defaulted after notice and warning.
  • Participating on the merits without timely asserting service or personal-jurisdiction defenses can waive those defenses.
  • For design-patent profits under § 289, gross sales alone do not establish total profit.

Why It Matters

The recommendation distinguishes design-patent disgorgement from Lanham Act profit awards: § 289 contains no statutory rule shifting to the defendant the burden to prove cost deductions. Defaulting sellers do not automatically expose their entire sales revenue to recovery.

It also illustrates that patent owners pursuing default relief against foreign marketplace sellers may obtain injunctive relief, but still must offer non-speculative evidence supporting the amount of any profit award.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top