Reported / Citable
Background
Edgar Samuel Palma-Godoy appeared with counsel before U.S. Magistrate Judge Matthew H. Watters for a felony guilty-plea proceeding. The case had been referred to the magistrate judge under a general order for the taking of a felony plea.
After Rule 11 admonishments, Palma-Godoy, with counsel’s advice, consented to having the magistrate judge take his plea. He pleaded guilty without a plea agreement to Count One of the indictment, charging illegal reentry into the United States.
The Court’s Holding
The magistrate judge found that Palma-Godoy understood the charge, penalties, and his constitutional and statutory rights; knowingly and voluntarily waived those rights; was competent to plead guilty; and entered the plea freely and voluntarily.
The magistrate judge also found a sufficient factual basis for the plea and found Palma-Godoy guilty of the charged offense. The court recommended that the district judge accept the guilty plea and enter a judgment of guilt; sentencing remains for the presiding district judge.
Key Takeaways
- The magistrate judge recommended acceptance of Palma-Godoy’s guilty plea to illegal reentry.
- The plea was entered without a plea agreement after Rule 11 admonishments.
- Parties have 14 days to object to the findings and recommendation.
Why It Matters
This is a plea-stage recommendation, not a final sentencing decision. Unless the district judge rejects the recommendation or sustains objections, the case will proceed to acceptance of the plea and sentencing.