Reported / Citable
Background
Ayesha S. Islam sued Villa Fresh Italian Kitchen after experiencing stomach cramping, gas, pain, and diarrhea shortly after eating a spinach stromboli. She alleged that the symptoms continued until the following day and that a restaurant employee gave her no verbal acknowledgment when she reported her condition.
Islam sought $400,000 in damages. She invoked federal-question and diversity jurisdiction, while alleging that both she and Villa Fresh Italian Kitchen were Texas citizens. She also applied to proceed without prepaying filing fees.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Dustin M. Howell granted Islam leave to proceed in forma pauperis after finding her indigent. But, in the required screening of an in forma pauperis complaint, the magistrate judge recommended that the district judge dismiss the action without prejudice under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(2)(B).
The recommendation rested on lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. Complete diversity was absent because Islam alleged that she and the defendant were both Texas citizens. Nor did the complaint identify a federal cause of action, and the magistrate judge found no apparent federal law supporting a claim based on this alleged single instance of food poisoning. Service was to be withheld unless the district judge declined to adopt the recommendation.
Key Takeaways
- A plaintiff cannot invoke diversity jurisdiction when she and any defendant share the same state citizenship.
- An alleged food-poisoning injury, without an identified federal claim, does not establish federal-question jurisdiction.
- The order granted fee-waiver status but only recommended dismissal; the district judge retained review authority and the parties could object.
Why It Matters
The decision underscores that federal courts must police jurisdiction at the outset, including when screening complaints filed in forma pauperis. State-law personal-injury claims generally require complete diversity or another independent basis for federal jurisdiction to remain in federal court.