Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Panza v. Travelers — Court denied remand after finding the Texas adjuster was improperly joined

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Paul Panza and Neely Tetley v. Travelers Personal Insurance Company and Natalie Ortega
Court
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas
Judge
Sidney A. Fitzwater
Date Decided
September 3, 2025
Docket No.
3:25-cv-01637-D
Topics
Removal, Improper Joinder, Insurance Claims, Civil Conspiracy

Background

Paul Panza and Neely Tetley alleged that their Dallas property sustained damage from a plumbing leak while insured under a Travelers Personal Insurance Company policy. Travelers retained Texas insurance adjuster Natalie Ortega to investigate and adjust the claim. The plaintiffs alleged that Travelers and Ortega failed to conduct a full, fair, and reasonable investigation, resulting in an underpayment.

The plaintiffs sued Travelers and Ortega in Texas state court, asserting Texas Insurance Code violations and civil conspiracy against Ortega, along with additional claims against Travelers. Travelers removed the case on diversity grounds, arguing that Ortega—who, like the plaintiffs, was a Texas citizen—had been improperly joined. The plaintiffs moved to remand, maintaining that Ortega’s citizenship defeated complete diversity and triggered the forum-defendant rule.

The Court’s Holding

The court denied the motion to remand, holding that Travelers met its heavy burden of demonstrating improper joinder because the pleadings provided no reasonable basis to predict that the plaintiffs could recover against Ortega. Applying the federal pleading standard to the allegations existing at removal, the court concluded that the plaintiffs had not plausibly stated a Texas Insurance Code claim against her.

The alleged statement that water damage occurred concerned the facts underlying the claim, not the policy’s terms, and the allegation that the damage was covered did not plausibly identify a misrepresentation about coverage. The remaining Insurance Code theories either applied to the insurer or required authority and obligations that the petition did not plausibly allege Ortega possessed, such as settlement authority or authority to affirm or deny coverage. Chapter 542 also applied only to insurers, not an individual adjuster.

The civil-conspiracy allegations were conclusory and did not plausibly establish the required agreement or unlawful acts. The claim also failed because a corporation generally cannot conspire with its agent acting within the scope of employment, and the plaintiffs did not allege that Ortega acted outside that scope for her personal benefit. The court therefore disregarded Ortega’s Texas citizenship for diversity and removal purposes.

Key Takeaways

  • An in-state insurance adjuster is improperly joined when the complaint supplies no reasonable basis to predict recovery against that adjuster under state law.
  • A Texas Insurance Code misrepresentation claim against an adjuster must plausibly concern policy details or coverage, not merely facts underlying the loss or a dispute over the amount owed.
  • A conspiracy claim between an insurer and its adjuster requires more than conclusory allegations, and ordinarily cannot rest on conduct by the adjuster within the scope of employment.

Why It Matters

The decision illustrates the claim-specific scrutiny federal courts apply when an insured names a nondiverse adjuster as a defendant and then seeks remand. Although defendants bear a heavy improper-joinder burden, formulaic allegations that track statutory language will not preserve an adjuster’s citizenship when the pleaded facts do not establish the adjuster’s personal liability.

For insurance litigants, the opinion also distinguishes duties attributable to insurers from those that may be imposed on individual adjusters. Plaintiffs seeking to defeat diversity jurisdiction must plead concrete facts connecting the adjuster’s own conduct and authority to a viable cause of action.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top