Reported / Citable
Background
The court ordered Cherevko’s dispute with Ernst & Young to arbitration in September 2025 under a valid arbitration agreement. Cherevko thereafter filed motions seeking to avoid arbitration and proceed in federal court.
On June 12, 2026, the magistrate judge directed Cherevko to initiate arbitration by July 1 and warned that noncompliance could result in a recommendation of dismissal. Ernst & Young had separately initiated JAMS arbitration in February 2026, but Cherevko continued to dispute its validity and declined to participate.
The Court’s Holding
The magistrate judge recommended that the district court construe Cherevko’s pending motions as an appeal of the September 2025 arbitration order, overrule his objections, and dismiss the action under Rule 41(b) for want of prosecution and failure to obey a court order.
The recommendation clarified that Cherevko need not open a second arbitration if Ernst & Young’s JAMS proceeding remains active. He nevertheless must cooperate in that arbitration under the parties’ agreement. The magistrate judge allowed that the recommendation could be withdrawn if Cherevko filed an advisory within 14 days demonstrating good-faith participation.
Key Takeaways
- This was a recommendation for district-court action, not a final dismissal order.
- A party cannot continue litigating objections to arbitration while refusing to participate in an ordered arbitration.
- Existing arbitration initiated by the opposing party may satisfy the need for a proceeding, but the resisting party must still cooperate.
Why It Matters
The recommendation illustrates the potential Rule 41(b) consequence of resisting a court-compelled arbitration after warnings and extensions. It also distinguishes between initiating arbitration and participating in an already-pending arbitration.