Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Blue Compass RV sought coverage under a Zurich auto dealers policy for approximately $1.36 million in alleged flood damage to RV inventory at its East Montpelier, Vermont property known as Lot 1368. Although the issued policy did not list Lot 1368 among the locations excluded from flood coverage, earlier spreadsheets exchanged during the parties’ negotiations identified both Lot 1368 and an adjacent property as not covered for flood losses.
Zurich denied the claim after the July 2023 flood, relying on an endorsement issued after the loss that added Lot 1368 to the excluded locations. Blue Compass sued for declaratory relief, breach of contract, violations of the Texas Insurance Code, and bad faith. Zurich counterclaimed for cancellation and reformation, asserting that the policy as issued did not reflect the parties’ agreement to exclude flood coverage for Lot 1368.
The Court’s Holding
The court denied Blue Compass’s motion for partial summary judgment on its breach-of-contract and Texas Insurance Code claims. It concluded that Blue Compass had not established the absence of a genuine dispute of material fact concerning the parties’ agreement and Zurich’s contention that the written policy failed to reflect their intended treatment of Lot 1368.
The court also denied Zurich’s cross-motion for summary judgment on policy reformation. Zurich filed that motion on October 2, 2025—48 days after the August 15 dispositive-motion deadline—and its earlier request for additional time to oppose Blue Compass’s motion neither sought permission to file a late dispositive motion nor disclosed an intention to do so.
Key Takeaways
- The policy as issued did not exclude Lot 1368 from flood coverage, but pre-policy spreadsheets identified the property as not covered, creating a factual dispute about the parties’ intended agreement.
- Blue Compass did not establish entitlement to judgment as a matter of law on its contract and Texas Insurance Code claims.
- Zurich’s reformation motion was denied as untimely because an extension to file an opposition brief did not extend the dispositive-motion deadline.
Why It Matters
The ruling leaves the central coverage and reformation issues unresolved for further proceedings. It illustrates that underwriting and negotiation records may prevent summary judgment even when the issued policy’s text appears to provide coverage.
The decision also underscores that a party seeking affirmative summary-judgment relief must comply with the scheduling order or expressly obtain an extension of the dispositive-motion deadline; extra time to respond to an opponent’s motion does not provide that relief.