Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Crest Foods, Inc., formerly the authorized U.S. franchisor for Nestlé Tollhouse cafés, and its owner and CEO, Ziad Dalal, entered into an asset purchase agreement with FAT Brands, Inc. FAT Brands agreed to acquire specified franchise-related assets and pay a purchase price consisting of an initial $1.75 million installment and later installments calculated using multiples of royalties earned by purchased stores. Stores converted on time to FAT Brands franchises generally generated a higher multiple.
After the final accounting, FAT Brands calculated the remaining purchase price as $16,973.01. Crest alleged that errors concerning at least 64 stores, including incorrect conversion dates, improperly reduced the amount owed and demanded $1,565,989.37. Plaintiffs sued for declaratory relief, breach of contract, unjust enrichment, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, contractual indemnification, and equitable reformation. FAT Brands moved to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction and failure to state a claim.
The Court’s Holding
The court rejected FAT Brands’ jurisdictional challenge. Whether Dalal possessed a contractual right to recover was a merits issue rather than a question of Article III standing, and plaintiffs adequately traced their alleged monetary injury to FAT Brands’ asserted breach.
The court nevertheless dismissed every claim under Rule 12(b)(6). The agreement’s exclusive-remedies clause barred the contract and implied-covenant claims by limiting relief for contractual breaches to indemnification. The indemnification claim was untimely because the agreement’s 12-month survival period expired on May 24, 2023, and Crest did not assert its claim until February 15, 2024. The court predicted that Delaware law would enforce that period and would not equitably toll it under the circumstances.
The court held that the unjust-enrichment and reformation claims were not themselves barred by the contractual limitations period, but dismissed them on other grounds. Reformation was supported only by conclusory allegations and did not plausibly identify a specific prior understanding that differed from the written agreement. Unjust enrichment was unavailable because an express agreement governed the parties’ relationship, and the declaratory-judgment claim failed after dismissal of its underlying claims. The court granted plaintiffs 28 days to file a second amended complaint.
Key Takeaways
- A challenge to a party’s right to recover under a contract concerns contractual standing and the merits, not necessarily Article III jurisdiction.
- The agreement’s exclusive-remedies provision confined breach claims to contractual indemnification, while its 12-month survival provision made the pleaded indemnification demand untimely.
- Although all claims were dismissed, the dismissal was accompanied by leave to amend because some potential claims were not necessarily foreclosed by the agreement.
Why It Matters
The decision illustrates the substantial effect Delaware law may give negotiated exclusive-remedy and survival provisions between sophisticated commercial parties, even when the limitations period expires before final performance is due. Parties structuring deferred purchase-price or earnout arrangements should ensure that contractual claim periods remain open long enough to address disputes arising from the final accounting.
It also underscores that alternative equitable theories do not automatically avoid a negotiated contract: reformation requires concrete allegations of a specific prior agreement, and unjust enrichment generally cannot replace contractual relief when a valid agreement governs the dispute.