Reported / Citable
Background
Reinelys Dairis Montilla Galarraga, a Venezuelan citizen, entered the United States in October 2022 and was paroled because of limited Border Patrol detention capacity. In January 2025, she pleaded nolo contendere in Texas state court to two counts of promoting prostitution and received two-year sentences. After her release under mandatory supervision, she was placed in immigration proceedings.
An immigration judge ordered Montilla Galarraga removed to Costa Rica or, alternatively, Venezuela on November 6, 2025. She waived appeal, making the order final that day. ICE took her into custody on May 13, 2026. She petitioned for habeas relief in July, arguing that continued detention was unlawful because Venezuela was not accepting deportations and seeking release under reasonable supervision conditions or, alternatively, a bond hearing.
The Court’s Holding
The district court granted the habeas petition and denied the government’s renewed summary-judgment motion. Applying 8 U.S.C. § 1231 and Zadvydas v. Davis, the court held that the six-month period during which post-removal-order detention is presumptively reasonable is rebuttable and does not categorically foreclose an earlier challenge. A detainee may obtain relief before six months by showing that removal is not reasonably foreseeable and detention therefore no longer serves its statutory purpose.
Montilla Galarraga made that showing even though she had been in post-removal-order custody for only about three months. The government acknowledged that Venezuela was not accepting deportations and could not say when it would resume doing so. The court found that the possibility conditions might change during the next three months did not establish reasonable foreseeability. It ordered her released within 48 hours, directed the return of her personal property and identity documents, and required a status update by August 27, 2026.
Key Takeaways
- The six-month presumption recognized in Zadvydas is not a bright-line authorization to detain every noncitizen for six months after a removal order becomes final.
- A detainee may rebut the presumption of reasonableness before six months by showing there is no significant likelihood of removal in the reasonably foreseeable future.
- The government’s hope that Venezuela might resume accepting deportations, without any indication when that could happen, did not justify continued detention.
Why It Matters
The decision recognizes that courts may grant Zadvydas relief before six months of post-removal-order detention when present diplomatic or logistical conditions make removal unforeseeable. The practical inquiry is whether detention remains reasonably connected to effectuating removal, not simply how many months the detainee has spent in custody.
For immigration practitioners, the ruling underscores the importance of evidence about a destination country’s current acceptance of deportees and the government’s ability to identify a concrete removal timeline.