Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Raitz Enterprises hired concrete subcontractor Javier Sanchez, Jr. to work on three construction projects. After defects appeared in the Iredell project, Raitz blamed Sanchez and withheld amounts owed across the projects. Sanchez maintained that defective concrete supplied by a company partially owned by Raitz’s owner caused the Iredell problems.
Sanchez sued for breach of contract, quantum meruit, and unjust enrichment, while Raitz counterclaimed for breach of contract and breach of an implied warranty. A jury found that Raitz breached the Woodlands and Iredell agreements and owed Sanchez for preparatory work on the Slab project. The trial court entered judgment awarding Sanchez $26,640 in damages and $87,417.50 in attorney’s fees.
The Court’s Holding
The Eleventh Court of Appeals affirmed. It held that legally and factually sufficient evidence supported the jury’s findings that Raitz—not Sanchez—breached the Iredell agreement. Because the jury found no breach by Sanchez, the substantial-performance doctrine did not apply, and Sanchez was not required to prove the cost of repairing the defective slab.
The court also upheld the challenged trial rulings. Any error in excluding testimony about repair costs was harmless because the jury found Sanchez was not liable; the proposed repair-cost instruction was therefore immaterial. The trial court acted within its discretion in rejecting Raitz’s late attempt to plead failure of presentment as a defense to attorney’s fees. Finally, counsel’s testimony and billing summaries sufficiently supported the fee award, and the summaries qualified as business records.
Key Takeaways
- Substantial performance applies when a contractor has breached but substantially completed the contract; it does not govern when the factfinder determines the contractor did not breach.
- Excluded evidence concerning repair damages is harmless when a supported no-liability finding prevents any recovery of those damages.
- Detailed billing summaries combined with counsel’s testimony can support a lodestar fee award even when some entries are redacted and the fees exceed the damages recovered.
Why It Matters
The decision emphasizes that responsibility for a construction defect is a fact question when the evidence supports competing causes. Appellate courts will not reweigh credibility determinations merely because a party’s contemporaneous messages appear inconsistent with its trial testimony.
It also illustrates that the size of a fee award relative to damages is relevant but not dispositive. Properly supported fees generated by lengthy, contentious litigation may remain recoverable even when they substantially exceed the underlying contract damages.