Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
A jury convicted David Lee Harrison of two counts of sexual assault and four counts of sexual performance by a child. The complainant, Harrison’s step-granddaughter, testified that Harrison repeatedly engaged in sexual contact with her, sent her sexually suggestive messages and photographs, and solicited nude images from her. Investigators searching Harrison’s electronic devices found internet history and images involving stepparent-stepchild, step-grandparent, and teenage sexual content.
Harrison initially objected to the search-history, photographic, and video evidence under Texas Rules of Evidence 403, 404(b), and 702. After an off-the-record discussion, however, the parties agreed to limit what the jury would initially receive: Harrison stipulated to admission of a video and to general testimony about the searches and images, while the remaining exhibits were withheld pending a further predicate and ruling. When the State offered those exhibits for publication to the jury the next day, Harrison stated, “No objection.” The jury imposed four 15-year sentences, one 18-year sentence, and one 20-year sentence, to run consecutively.
The Court’s Holding
The Seventh Court of Appeals affirmed. It held that Harrison forfeited his evidentiary complaint because the trial court had expressly required a renewed bench conference and ruling before the withheld exhibits could be shown to the jury, yet Harrison did not renew his objections and instead affirmatively stated that he had no objection. Nothing in the record indicated that Harrison or the trial court understood that statement as preserving his earlier objections.
The court also concluded that, even if Harrison had preserved the issue, admitting the evidence would not have been an abuse of discretion under Rule 403. The pornography-related searches closely mirrored Harrison’s familial relationship with the complainant and were therefore highly probative of intent. The State also had a substantial need for corroborating evidence because there was no medical evidence, the complainant was the only witness to the abuse, and Harrison’s defense challenged her credibility. The evidence’s inflammatory character did not substantially outweigh its probative value.
Key Takeaways
- A defendant may forfeit an earlier evidentiary objection by later stating “no objection” when the evidence is offered to the jury.
- A running objection does not eliminate the need to object again when the trial court expressly conditions a later offer on a renewed conference and ruling.
- Pornography or search-history evidence mirroring the defendant’s relationship to the complainant may be highly probative of intent in a child-sex-abuse prosecution.
Why It Matters
The opinion underscores the importance of renewing objections after a trial court defers admission or requires a later ruling. Counsel cannot safely rely on an earlier running objection when the record subsequently reflects an unqualified statement of “no objection.”
It also illustrates how Texas courts assess digital sexual-content evidence under Rule 403: a close connection between the content and the charged relationship, combined with the State’s need to corroborate a complainant whose credibility is attacked, can support admission despite the evidence’s prejudicial nature.