Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Charles S. Gaither, who is African-American, alleged that Bank of America employees discriminated against him in July 2020 when he attempted to pay off his mortgage. A bank representative rejected Gaither’s personal check, accused him of fraud, and told him payment required a certified cashier’s check or wire transfer. A wire transfer attempted the next day failed because a bank employee wrote down the wrong account number. Gaither ultimately paid the mortgage on July 16 with a credit-union check that he alleged was neither certified nor a cashier’s check.
Gaither sued Bank of America and purported branch manager Jessica Carter on January 6, 2025, asserting racial discrimination under 42 U.S.C. § 1981, intentional infliction of emotional distress, a claim under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, and a Texas Labor Code claim. The district court dismissed the action with prejudice for failure to state a claim and denied postjudgment relief and leave to amend. Gaither appealed but did not brief his Texas Labor Code claim, thereby abandoning it.
The Court’s Holding
The Fifth Circuit affirmed because Gaither filed suit after the applicable limitations periods had expired. His post-contract-formation § 1981 claim was governed by the four-year federal limitations period in 28 U.S.C. § 1658, while his DTPA claim had a two-year limitations period. The alleged conduct occurred in July 2020, but Gaither waited nearly four and a half years to sue.
Gaither did not plead facts supporting equitable tolling. Although he alleged that Bank of America concealed the branch manager’s identity and that a conversation with the manager revealed the discrimination, he did not state when the conversation occurred, describe diligent efforts to contact the manager, or explain how the bank obstructed those efforts. Amendment would have been futile because Gaither supplied no additional facts demonstrating diligence, even on appeal or at oral argument. The court also affirmed dismissal of the claims against Carter as time-barred, although it recognized that dismissal solely for lack of service ordinarily must be without prejudice.
Key Takeaways
- A post-contract-formation § 1981 claim made possible by the 1991 amendment to the statute is subject to the four-year limitations period under 28 U.S.C. § 1658.
- Equitable tolling requires specific facts showing both diligent pursuit of rights and an extraordinary circumstance outside the plaintiff’s control that prevented timely filing.
- An appellate court may affirm on any ground supported by the record, including limitations, even when the district court relied on lack of service to dismiss a defendant.
Why It Matters
The decision underscores that generalized allegations of concealment do not establish equitable tolling. A plaintiff must identify dates, describe concrete efforts to investigate or pursue the claim, and explain how circumstances beyond the plaintiff’s control prevented a timely filing.
It also clarifies that Fifth Circuit precedent applying Texas’s two-year personal-injury period to some § 1981 claims does not control post-contract-formation claims made possible by the Civil Rights Act of 1991; those claims receive the federal four-year period.