Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Lopez-Ysturiz v. Vergara — Court orders release of Venezuelan detainee held without bond hearing

Reported / Citable

Case
Neider David Lopez-Ysturiz v. Miguel Vergara, Field Office Director, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court, Western District of Texas (San Antonio Division)
Date Decided
June 15, 2026
Docket No.
SA-26-CA-03537-XR
Topics
Immigration detention, Habeas corpus, Procedural due process, Section 1225

Background

Neider David Lopez-Ysturiz, a Venezuelan national, entered the United States in December 2023 and was placed in removal proceedings under 8 U.S.C. § 1229a before being released into the country. On May 13, 2026, ICE re-arrested him and detained him at the South Texas ICE Processing Center in Pearsall, Texas — this time without affording him a bond hearing.

The government justified the no-bond detention under a policy shift that took effect in mid-2025. ICE Acting Director Todd Lyons issued an internal memorandum reinterpreting the INA to classify all noncitizens who entered without inspection as “applicants for admission” subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b) rather than discretionary detention under § 1226(a), which carries a right to a bond hearing. The Board of Immigration Appeals codified that position in Matter of Yajure Hurtado, 29 I. & N. Dec. 216 (BIA 2025). In February 2026, the Fifth Circuit upheld the statutory interpretation in Buenrostro-Mendez v. Bondi, No. 25-20496 (5th Cir. Feb. 6, 2026), foreclosing INA-based challenges — but expressly leaving the constitutional due process question open.

Lopez-Ysturiz filed a § 2241 habeas petition arguing that detaining him indefinitely without any individualized assessment of flight risk or dangerousness violated his Fifth Amendment right to procedural due process. The government responded that statutory jurisdiction-stripping provisions barred review, that failure to exhaust administrative remedies defeated the petition, and that DHS v. Thuraissigiam, 591 U.S. 103 (2020), stripped noncitizens in his position of any due process right to a bond hearing.

The Court’s Holding

Judge Xavier Rodriguez granted the petition and ordered Lopez-Ysturiz released by June 17, 2026. The court held that none of the INA’s jurisdiction-stripping provisions apply to challenges to detention (as opposed to removal proceedings or discretionary detention decisions), and that exhaustion of administrative remedies would be futile given the BIA’s binding adverse precedent. Crucially, the court held that Buenrostro-Mendez does not resolve the constitutional claim because the Fifth Circuit — at the government’s own concession during oral argument — addressed only the statutory question.

On the merits, the court applied the Mathews v. Eldridge balancing test and found that all three factors favor requiring an individualized bond hearing. The court distinguished Thuraissigiam on two grounds: first, Lopez-Ysturiz challenges only his detention, not the admission process; second, unlike the petitioner stopped twenty-five yards from the border in Thuraissigiam, Lopez-Ysturiz entered the United States in December 2023 and was released into the interior, giving him substantial connections to the country and full Fifth Amendment protection under Zadvydas v. Davis and Wong Wing v. United States.

The court also expressly departed from its own prior holdings in Canales-Melgar v. Noem and Goguev v. Noem, in which it had applied the “entry fiction” to detainees with substantial interior presence, adopting instead the growing district-court consensus that the entry fiction governs admission proceedings only and does not override due process rights in detention challenges brought by noncitizens who have established a substantial presence inside the United States.

Key Takeaways

  • The Fifth Circuit’s Buenrostro-Mendez decision forecloses statutory (INA-based) challenges to mandatory detention under § 1225(b), but it does not resolve — and the government’s own counsel conceded it did not raise — the constitutional due process question.
  • Thuraissigiam‘s “entry fiction” limits due process rights in admission proceedings; it does not eliminate a noncitizen’s right to an individualized bond hearing when the noncitizen has entered the interior and established substantial connections in the United States.
  • Noncitizens who were previously released or paroled into the interior — and thus already cleared as posing no flight risk or danger — have a Fifth Amendment procedural due process right to an individualized hearing before being re-detained without bond.
  • Exhaustion of administrative remedies is excused when the BIA has recently issued binding precedent adverse to the petitioner’s claim, making administrative appeal futile.
  • The court explicitly overruled its own earlier decisions applying the entry fiction to interior detainees, signaling a significant doctrinal shift within this district.

Why It Matters

This decision is part of a rapidly growing body of district court rulings — across the Western District of Texas and beyond — holding that the 2025 policy shift reclassifying interior noncitizens as § 1225(b) “applicants for admission” violates the Fifth Amendment when applied to people who have lived in the United States and were previously vetted and released. With Buenrostro-Mendez having closed the statutory door, the constitutional route is now the primary avenue of relief, and courts are consistently finding it viable for noncitizens with substantial interior presence.

For practitioners, the case clarifies that a habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 remains available to challenge detention — as distinct from removal — notwithstanding the INA’s jurisdiction-stripping provisions, and that the constitutional question the Supreme Court reserved in Jennings v. Rodriguez and Johnson v. Arteaga-Martinez is now being resolved in the lower courts in detainees’ favor. Attorneys representing noncitizens detained under the Lyons Memo policy should expect courts in this circuit to apply Mathews balancing and require bond hearings for clients who entered the interior and were previously released.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top